Universities should judge complaint resolution by how the process works for students, not by how few complaints arrive. A credible evaluation asks seven questions: can students find and use the route, are cases resolved within a stated time, is the procedure fair, can students escalate to an independent body, does the institution report what it learns, are remedies carried out, and is personal information protected. Official guidance in England and Wales, Australia and Europe sets out these expectations, and research shows why a low complaint count can hide distrust rather than signal satisfaction.
Why a small number of complaints proves little
A complaint count is the product of several things at once: how often something goes wrong, whether students recognize it as something they can complain about, whether they know the route, whether they believe complaining is safe and worthwhile, and whether the institution records what it receives. A fall in any of these produces fewer complaints. Only the first is good news.
The Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education (OIA), the independent student complaints scheme for England and Wales, states this directly in its Good Practice Framework on handling complaints and academic appeals (revised December 2022): "A low volume of student complaints is not of itself an indicator of success." The same framework says that providers with an open culture of feedback "should expect to receive complaints and appeals," and that good analysis considers where complaints have not been received and which groups of students are not using the processes.
Survey evidence on one serious category of concern illustrates the gap. In the Office for Students (OfS) sexual misconduct survey 2025, offered to final-year undergraduates in England after the National Student Survey, only 13.2 percent of students who experienced sexual harassment in the previous 12 months made a formal report or complaint to their university or college. The survey received 51,920 responses, a response rate of 12.1 percent, and the OfS notes that groups with higher response rates also tended to report higher prevalence, so the figures are not a simple population estimate. Among all respondents, 67.5 percent said they felt confident about where to seek support and 29.3 percent said they did not.
Research points the same way. Aguilar and Baek (2020) analyzed 2,343 crowdsourced accounts of sexual harassment in academia and found that students were 1.6 times more likely than faculty and staff respondents not to report their experiences. The authors caution that the survey spread through social networks and likely suffers from selection bias, so the result describes reporting patterns in that sample, not prevalence. Multicultural inclusion raises similar reporting questions; our article on measuring multicultural inclusion covers harassment rules and discrimination reporting, so they are not repeated here.
What official bodies expect from a complaints process
Three sets of official expectations, from different systems, describe what a sound process looks like. None of them provides a score, and none should be read as legal advice for an individual case.
England and Wales: the OIA Good Practice Framework
The framework sets out ten core principles, grouped as accessible and clear; fair, independent and confidential; inclusive; flexible, proportionate and timely; and improving the student experience. It describes a normal sequence of early resolution, a formal stage and a review stage. Three concrete expectations make it useful for evaluation:
- Time: it is good practice to complete a formal complaint or academic appeal, and any review, within 90 calendar days, telling the student and updating them if an extension is needed.
- Closure: a student whose complaint or appeal is not upheld at review should be told the outcome in a Completion of Procedures Letter as soon as possible and within 28 days, with the reasons and the right to complain to the OIA. The time limit for bringing a complaint to the OIA is 12 months.
- Learning and accountability: providers should record all formal and review-stage complaints, analyze them for trends, share summary information with staff, students and student representatives, and name senior managers who are accountable for complaint handling.
On confidentiality, the framework asks providers to share information only with those who need it, and it states that asking a student to sign a confidentiality or non-disclosure agreement as part of settling a complaint is not good practice, because learning from the complaint can be lost.
Australia: the Threshold Standards and the national ombudsman
Standard 2.4 of the Higher Education Standards Framework (Threshold Standards) 2021, in the compilation dated 14 July 2026, requires that students have access to mechanisms capable of resolving grievances about any aspect of their experience; that formal complaints and appeals are resolved in a timely way, without charge or at reasonable cost, consistently, fairly and without reprisal; that processes include confidentiality, independent advice, advocacy and review by an independent third party; that decisions and reasons are recorded and given in writing; and that upheld complaints lead to prompt action. The 2026 compilation adds that processes must be transparent and designed and periodically reviewed with students and staff, including people with lived experience of discrimination, harassment, victimization or violence, so that they are accessible, easy to navigate and culturally safe.
Escalation in Australia has also changed. Evers and Kamvounias (2025) describe how student complaints about public universities were handled for years by nine separate state and territory ombudsmen, and report that legislation passed in late 2024 established a National Student Ombudsman within the Commonwealth Ombudsman, to begin taking complaints in February 2025.
Europe: the Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance
The Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance in the European Higher Education Area (ESG 2015), written by ENQA, the European Students' Union, EUA and EURASHE, place complaints inside teaching quality. The guidelines to Standard 1.3 on student-centred learning list, among the features of good implementation, that it "has appropriate procedures for dealing with students' complaints." The ESG do not define those procedures, which leaves national agencies to set the detail.
What the research shows about fairness, outcomes and trust
Fair procedures and fair outcomes are not the same thing
Consumer research on complaint handling offers a useful contrast. A meta-analysis of 60 independent studies by Orsingher, Valentini and de Angelis (2010) found that satisfaction with complaint handling was affected most by distributive justice (the fairness of the outcome), then by interactional justice (how the complainant was treated), and only weakly by procedural justice (the fairness of the process). In a university setting, Waqas, Ali and Khan (2014) surveyed 312 students online and found that all three justice dimensions were significant predictors of satisfaction with service recovery, while describing their findings as tentative because of the sample and sampling technique. Both sources were read in abstract only.
Research on how students view university authority more broadly suggests that process carries more weight for trust than for satisfaction. Główczewski and Burdziej (2023) ran two cross-sectional surveys of students at Polish public universities (N = 315 and N = 751, the second designed to approximate a nationally representative sample). In the second study, students' experience of procedural fairness was a stronger predictor of the perceived legitimacy of university authorities (standardized coefficient 0.58) than their experience of distributive fairness (0.21). The authors note that the cross-sectional design means they "cannot draw strong conclusions in terms of causality," and their fairness measures covered university decisions in general, not complaint handling specifically.
Taken together, these studies suggest that a satisfaction question asked after a complaint mostly captures how students feel about what they received, while trust in the institution may depend more on whether the process was fair. An evaluation that measures only post-complaint satisfaction can therefore miss the dimension most associated with legitimacy. This is an interpretation across studies with different designs and populations, not a tested finding.
Procedures can fail the students who most need them
Bull and Page (2022) interviewed 15 women (14 students and one early career researcher) who reported or disclosed staff sexual misconduct to UK institutions between 2010 and 2017. Six were blocked or dissuaded from reporting or could not get a formal complaint acted on. Only one interviewee reached the OIA; the main reason the others did not was that they could not complete lengthy and distressing internal processes, and none of those who obtained a remedy thought it had put things right. The reasons interviewees gave for not escalating included lack of faith that it would help, lack of time on an international student visa, the outcomes they wanted not being available, and unclear remit. The study is small and qualitative and focused on one type of complaint, but it shows how an external route can be formally available and practically unreachable.
Ombudsman casework repeats the same lessons
Evers and Kamvounias (2025) analyzed 112 student complaint case studies published in 144 annual reports and other publications of nine Australian ombudsmen between 2007 and 2023. The ombudsmen found no maladministration in 10 of the 112 cases. Across the rest, the authors identified five recurring lessons: communication should be accurate, clear and updated; information should be accurate, clear and adequate; decision-makers should consider individual circumstances; decisions should follow proper process, consider all relevant matters and give reasons; and complaints should be managed properly. Where student status was recorded (50 cases), 46 complainants were international students. The authors stress that published case studies are selected by each ombudsman and cannot be treated as representative.
What national complaint data can and cannot tell you
The OIA Annual Report 2025 gives a detailed public picture of escalated complaints in one system. The OIA received 4,234 complaints in 2025, up 17 percent on 2024 (3,613) and about 2.8 times the 1,517 received in 2016. It resolved 3,950 complaints, closed more than 90 percent within six months, and reported an average case handling time of 81 days.
| Outcome | Share | What it means for evaluation |
|---|---|---|
| Justified | 2% | Complaint upheld in full |
| Partly Justified | 5% | Complaint upheld in part |
| Settled | 13% | Resolved through a settlement |
| Not Justified (reasonable offer made) | 7% | Complaint had some merit, and the provider had already offered a fair remedy |
| Not Justified | 43% | Complaint not upheld |
| Withdrawn | 9% | Complaint withdrawn |
| Not Eligible | 20% | Not eligible for review; 70% of these were brought too early, before internal procedures were complete |
Two details matter for anyone assessing institutional responsiveness. First, the OIA reports that most complaints brought to it prematurely came from students who had begun their provider's process but felt they had waited too long for a decision; it describes delays as "a symptom of a system under strain." Second, complainants are not a cross-section of students: in 2025, 42 percent of students complaining to the OIA disclosed a disability, and the OIA reports that international students are overrepresented. Academic appeals made up 42 percent of complaints and service issues 33 percent.
These figures describe escalated cases. They have no student-population denominator, the report presents sector-level totals, and a rise can reflect better awareness as easily as worse service. National totals are context for interpreting an institution's own data, not a benchmark for it.
An evaluation framework for complaint resolution
The matrix below is an editorial framework proposed by this article; it is not the UNIRANKS methodology and does not describe how UNIRANKS evaluates institutions. It turns the official expectations and research above into questions that a student, quality team or researcher can check. It sets no thresholds, because none of the sources sets universal ones.
| Dimension | Question to ask | Evidence that answers it | Weak evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | Can every student group find, understand and use the route, including online, part-time and international students? | Published procedure in plain language; awareness and confidence items in student surveys, broken down by group; use rates compared with survey-reported problems | A policy document that exists but is hard to find |
| Timeliness | Are cases closed within the stated period, and are students told about delays? | Published target times and the share of cases closed within them, by stage | An average time with no distribution or stage breakdown |
| Procedural fairness | Are students heard, given reasons and treated without reprisal? | Written reasons in outcome letters; independent decision-makers at review; post-process survey items on being heard and understanding the decision | Satisfaction with the outcome alone |
| Escalation | Is an independent external route named, explained and reachable? | Completion letters issued on time; signposting to the ombudsman or regulator; share of escalated cases found ineligible because internal procedures were unfinished | A footnote mentioning an ombudsman |
| Transparency | Does the institution report what it receives and learns? | Annual complaint reports to governing bodies and student representatives, with categories, outcomes and changes made | Raw complaint counts presented as performance |
| Follow-up | Are upheld remedies carried out and recurring causes fixed? | Tracking of remedy completion; documented policy or practice changes linked to complaint themes | Apologies with no record of action |
| Privacy and confidentiality | Is information shared only as needed, without silencing complainants? | Stated confidentiality rules; no non-disclosure agreements in settlements; anonymized reporting of trends | Confidentiality used to avoid reporting any outcomes |
Our interpretation
The evidence supports three conclusions. First, complaint volume is ambiguous: the OIA framework, the OfS survey and the reporting research all indicate that silence can reflect low confidence or blocked routes, so volume should only be read alongside survey evidence on problems experienced and trust in the process. Second, timeliness is measurable and consequential: the OIA links many premature escalations to students who felt they had waited too long, which makes stage-by-stage closure times one of the most informative indicators an institution can publish. Third, fairness of process deserves separate measurement from satisfaction with outcomes, because the research suggests they relate to different things.
What remains uncertain is equally important. No study we found links specific complaint-handling practices to later student outcomes such as continuation, and most institutional complaint data are not public, so comparisons between institutions rest on self-reported procedures rather than audited performance.
Practical steps
For students
- Before enrolling, look for a published complaints procedure with stated time limits and the name of the external body that reviews unresolved complaints.
- If you complain, keep dated records and ask for written reasons at each stage, and ask for the formal closing letter that confirms internal procedures are complete.
For university administrators and quality teams
- Report closure times by stage and the share of cases meeting your own targets, not only totals.
- Compare complaint use with student survey data on problems and confidence, by group, to find who is not using the process.
- Ask complainants, after closure, separate questions about the outcome and about whether they were heard and understood the decision.
- Track whether upheld remedies are completed and publish what changed as a result of complaints.
For researchers
- Study complaint handling with designs that can follow students over time, and test whether procedural fairness in complaints is linked to trust, continuation or wellbeing.
- Develop and validate short instruments for perceived fairness of complaint processes that can be used across systems.
Limitations
This article draws on six peer-reviewed sources: four were read in full (Aguilar and Baek; Bull and Page; Evers and Kamvounias; Główczewski and Burdziej) and two from abstracts only (Orsingher and colleagues; Waqas and colleagues). The two justice studies of complaint satisfaction are older than 2020, and one is from consumer services rather than higher education. The official sources cover England and Wales, Australia and the European framework; other systems have different rules and escalation bodies. Two of the studies concern sexual misconduct, a category where barriers to reporting are especially high, so their findings should not be generalized to all complaint types. The OfS survey had a 12.1 percent response rate with evidence of response differences between groups. None of the sources allows causal conclusions about which practices improve outcomes.
Related reading on UNIRANKS
For how complaint evidence fits alongside surveys and administrative data, see how universities should measure student experience. International students face particular barriers to support and complaints, covered in what support universities should provide international students. More research on this dimension is collected in Student Experience & Satisfaction.
Editorial disclosure
UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes a Student Experience & Satisfaction dimension. This article reviews independent research on university complaint resolution. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.
Research References
- Aguilar, S. J., & Baek, C. (2020). Sexual harassment in academe is underreported, especially by students in the life and physical sciences. PLOS ONE, 15(3), e0230312. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0230312 (verified 22 November 2026)
- Bull, A., & Page, T. (2022). The Governance of Complaints in UK Higher Education: Critically Examining 'Remedies' for Staff Sexual Misconduct. Social & Legal Studies, 31(1), 27-49. https://doi.org/10.1177/09646639211002243 (verified 22 November 2026)
- Evers, M., & Kamvounias, P. (2025). Ombudsmen and Australian universities: learning from student complaints. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 47(3), 249-265. https://doi.org/10.1080/1360080X.2025.2457177 (verified 22 November 2026)
- Główczewski, M., & Burdziej, S. (2023). (In)justice in academia: procedural fairness, students' academic identification, and perceived legitimacy of university authorities. Higher Education, 86(1), 163-184. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-022-00907-8 (verified 22 November 2026)
- Orsingher, C., Valentini, S., & de Angelis, M. (2010). A meta-analysis of satisfaction with complaint handling in services. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 38(2), 169-186. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11747-009-0155-z (verified 22 November 2026)
- Waqas, M., Ali, H., & Khan, M. A. (2014). An investigation of effects of justice recovery dimensions on students' satisfaction with service recovery in higher education environment. International Review on Public and Nonprofit Marketing, 11(3), 263-284. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12208-014-0120-5 (verified 22 November 2026)
Sources
- Good Practice Framework: Handling complaints and academic appeals (revised December 2022). Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education. https://www.oiahe.org.uk/media/otzp4do5/gpf-handling-complaints-and-academic-appeals.pdf (accessed 22 November 2026)
- OIA Annual Report 2025. Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education. https://www.oiahe.org.uk/media/xfljp10u/oia-annual-report-2025.pdf (accessed 22 November 2026)
- Sexual misconduct survey 2025: Analysis of results report (OfS 2025.61). Office for Students. https://www.officeforstudents.org.uk/media/qs3j3kjz/sexual-misconduct-survey-2025-analysis-report.pdf (accessed 22 November 2026)
- Higher Education Standards Framework (Threshold Standards) 2021, Compilation No. 2 (compilation date 14 July 2026). Australian Government, Federal Register of Legislation. https://www.legislation.gov.au/F2021L00488/2026-07-14/2026-07-14/text/original/pdf (accessed 22 November 2026)
- Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance in the European Higher Education Area (ESG) 2015. ENQA, ESU, EUA and EURASHE. https://www.enqa.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/ESG_2015.pdf (accessed 22 November 2026)
