Do International University Partnerships Deliver Meaningful Results?

Share

International university partnerships can deliver meaningful results, but only some of them do, and the number of agreements a university has signed says little about which ones. The research reviewed here points to a consistent pattern: partnerships produce measurable value when they are embedded in degrees, credits, staff time, budgets and quality assurance, and when partners share decisions as well as activities. A memorandum of understanding records an intention. A functioning partnership leaves evidence: students who completed a joint program, credits that were recognized, staff who co-taught or co-supervised, and outcomes reported against a clear denominator. More agreements is not the same as better internationalization.

Why a count of agreements tells you so little

Partnership lists are easy to compile and hard to interpret. A memorandum of understanding (MOU) usually states that two institutions intend to cooperate; it does not, by itself, commit either side to admit students, recognize credits, share teaching or fund anything. That is why a long list of partner logos can coexist with very little activity.

The research on the European Universities Initiative, a European Commission program designed to build long-term transnational alliances, shows this gap even inside well-funded partnerships. In a study based on nine interviews with coordinators, programme managers and European Commission staff in three early alliances (conducted in spring 2020) plus document analysis, Charret and Chankseliani (2023) found that one alliance listed many associated partners in its official factsheet, yet interviewees described the roles those associates might play as still only "ideas" at the time. A listed partner, in other words, was not yet an active one.

The same problem appears in participation figures. The European Commission's 2025 report on the outcomes of the initiative, prepared by PPMI, states that about 83% of faculties at partner institutions take part in alliance activities, then immediately cautions that the figure depends on how involvement is defined. Interviews showed that "some alliances might consider that a faculty is involved if just one student or staff member takes part in alliance activities" (European Commission and PPMI, 2025). A partnership indicator without a definition and a denominator can describe almost anything.

What separates a functioning partnership from a paper one

Joint, double and consecutive degrees

Degree programs are among the clearest tests of commitment because they require partners to agree on curriculum, admission, assessment and award. Knight (2011), in a conceptual article, proposed working definitions that remain useful: a joint degree program awards one qualification conferred jointly by the partners; a double or multiple degree program awards two or more individual qualifications at equivalent levels; and a consecutive degree program awards qualifications at consecutive levels, such as a bachelor's and a master's.

Knight's analysis also explains why the existence of such a program is not proof of quality. Jointly conferred degrees can face legal obstacles, because national rules do not always allow a university to award a qualification together with a foreign institution, and a student may then hold a credential that neither country fully recognizes. Double degrees are legally simpler, but Knight warns that counting the same student workload or learning outcomes toward two degrees can put academic integrity at risk. The question for an evaluator is therefore not "does a double degree exist?" but "how are completion requirements set, and is the award recognized?"

Mobility that is built into the program

Mobility agreements can sit unused for years. In contrast, the European Commission's requirements for Erasmus Mundus Joint Masters, as published in the Erasmus+ Programme Guide, show what built-in mobility looks like: a consortium of at least three higher education institutions from three countries; a jointly designed and fully integrated curriculum; compulsory physical mobility for all enrolled students, with at least two study periods in two countries, each worth at least one semester (30 ECTS credits or equivalent); and a mechanism for recognizing study periods agreed within the consortium at the application stage. These are program design rules, not evidence of outcomes, but they illustrate the difference between permission to move and an obligation the partners have organized in advance. How mobility participation itself should be measured is covered in our companion article on measuring international student mobility.

Shared teaching, co-supervision and joint projects

Knight (2011) notes that student travel is not required in every joint program, and that visiting professors, distance courses and joint virtual research projects can provide alternatives. This matters for evaluation: a partnership can be highly active with modest student mobility if staff teach across institutions, co-supervise theses or doctorates, and run shared courses. The evidence an evaluator should look for is concrete: named courses in the catalog, teaching assignments, co-supervision agreements, and theses completed under them. We did not find recent peer-reviewed evidence on co-supervision outcomes that met this article's verification standard, so we treat it here as a type of evidence to request rather than as a documented effect.

Joint research publications are one further signal of engagement, but they measure research collaboration, not the quality of a partnership or of the institutions involved. Research performance is discussed separately in our Academic & Research Performance section.

What the European Universities evidence shows about results

The European Universities Initiative is useful as a case because it is large, publicly documented and explicitly designed for long-term cooperation. The European Commission's initiative page describes 73 alliances with almost 650 higher education institutions. The Commission's 2025 outcomes report, which draws on desk research, stakeholder consultation and monitoring data collected in the second half of 2023 from 38 of the 41 alliances selected in the 2019 and 2020 calls, reports that the alliances had set up more than 600 joint study programmes and courses, including around 160 joint degree programmes, and more than 430 short courses leading to micro-credentials. It also reports, in relative terms, a 400% increase in intra-alliance student mobility and a 200% increase in staff mobility over the first three years of operation, while acknowledging that absolute numbers remain far from the initiative's 50% student mobility target.

The same report lists persistent obstacles: legal and administrative barriers to designing and awarding joint degrees; difficulty scaling participation beyond a minority of students and departments; limited access for students with fewer opportunities, with references to housing, cost of living and wellbeing; insufficient time and career recognition for staff; and a project-based funding model that does not match a long-term strategy. These are self-reported and stakeholder-based findings from a commissioned study, and the report itself describes its data as a snapshot.

Two peer-reviewed studies add context. Charret and Chankseliani (2023) concluded that the early alliances relied on pre-existing higher education and research partnerships while experimenting with new institutional forms. Sipos (2026), using documentary policy analysis and a legal-status mapping of 65 funded alliances and eight alliances holding a Seal of Excellence, argues that official evaluation remains output-oriented and largely reflects periods of active funding. Sipos reports that 21 alliances had verified pathways to legal personality, concentrated in the earliest cohorts, and reads this as evidence of formalization rather than financial resilience. His scenario analysis suggests that central teams, shared platforms and alliance services are more exposed to a funding withdrawal than programs and academic networks already embedded in member universities. As he puts it, "The risk is that continuity can be mistaken for sustainability."

Sipos also proposes an outcome hierarchy that is directly useful outside Europe: project outputs (meetings, pilots, temporary posts, mobility calls, platforms); participant outcomes (learning, professional development, networks); institutional outcomes (curricula embedded in catalogs, recognized credits, continuing staff, recurrent budgets, stable shared services, governance rules); and system-level outcomes (regulatory learning, European degree coordination, cross-border infrastructure, regional innovation, and inclusion and diffusion beyond alliance members).

Who participates, and who decides?

A partnership can be active and still be unequal. Luthuli, Daniel and Corbin (2024) studied a partnership between a northern higher education institution and several southern institutions focused on nutrition education and research, using 13 in-depth interviews conducted between February and June 2022. The partnership was built on lessons from an earlier project, yet the northern partner held two roles at once, as an equal partner and as the distributor of project funds, which created a conflict of roles. Partners also came to be described as "implementing" or "supportive" according to their resources. The authors report that roles and resources were the greatest contributors to power imbalances and caused delays in project activities.

Inequality can also operate at the level of access to partnerships. Sipos (2026) warns that continued competitive funding could institutionalize inequalities if earlier alliances repeatedly secure larger portfolios because they have more proposal-writing capacity and established reputations. For evaluators, this means a partnership should be judged not only on what it produces but on who can take part, who sets priorities and who controls the budget.

Quality assurance and recognition: the test of a joint program

A joint program delivers value to students only if its quality is assured and its awards and credits are recognized. Several European and global instruments set out how this is meant to work.

  • European Approach for Quality Assurance of Joint Programmes. Ministers of the European Higher Education Area adopted it in the Yerevan Communiqué of May 2015. According to a 2019 presentation by the European Quality Assurance Register for Higher Education (EQAR), it allows a single external review of a joint program by an EQAR-registered agency, using agreed standards based on the European Standards and Guidelines, without additional national criteria. Its eligibility standard covers joint design and delivery and a cooperation agreement; the review panel has at least four members from at least two of the countries involved, including a student. The same presentation noted that automatic recognition of the result was possible in some, but not all, countries.
  • Erasmus Mundus Joint Masters. The Programme Guide states that, at application stage, full partner institutions must show they have met the external quality assurance requirements of their jurisdiction for the joint program, through the European Approach where national legislation allows, through a specific accreditation or evaluation of the joint program, or through accreditation of each national component.
  • Lisbon Recognition Convention. Developed by the Council of Europe and UNESCO and adopted in 1997, it provides, as the ENIC-NARIC networks summarize, that a foreign qualification must be recognized unless the recognizing authority can show a substantial difference.
  • UNESCO Global Convention on the Recognition of Qualifications concerning Higher Education. Adopted in Paris on 25 November 2019, it defines an international joint degree as a single degree conferred jointly by institutions in more than one country, and its Article V requires qualifications from international joint degrees and other joint programs to be assessed using the same criteria applied to programs undertaken in a single country.

For a reader assessing a partnership claim, the practical point is simple: ask which quality assurance procedure the joint program went through, which agency carried it out, and in which countries the resulting award is recognized.

Paper partnership or active partnership: evidence to request

Signals that distinguish a paper partnership from an active one (editorial checklist)
DimensionPaper partnership signalActive partnership evidenceEvidence to request
AgreementSigned MOU, logo on a partner pageOperational agreement with named activities, responsibilities and review datesAgreement type, start date, last renewal, named contacts
Degrees"Opportunities for joint programs"Joint, double or consecutive degree with enrolled and graduated studentsIntake and completion by cohort; how completion requirements avoid double counting
MobilityExchange agreement with no recent flowsMobility built into the curriculum with credits agreed in advanceFlows in both directions by year; share of credits recognized
Teaching and supervisionOccasional guest lecturesCo-taught courses, shared catalog, co-supervised thesesCourse codes, teaching assignments, completed co-supervisions
Joint projects and facilitiesAnnounced centers without staff or budgetShared services or facilities with continuing staff and recurrent fundingStaffing, budget source, what continues after a grant ends
DurationRenewed on paper without activityActivity sustained across funding cyclesActivity history over several years
Participation and accessOpen to "all students" with no dataParticipation reported against an eligible population, with support for students with fewer opportunitiesParticipants divided by eligible students; financial support offered
Governance and equityOne partner controls funds and agendaShared decision-making, transparent budget rolesGovernance rules, budget allocation, partner roles
Quality assurance and recognitionNo information on accreditationExternal review of the joint program and recognized awardsReviewing agency, procedure used, countries recognizing the award
OutcomesActivity counts onlyParticipant and institutional outcomes defined in advanceStated objectives, indicators, results and limitations

An editorial framework for evaluating partnership results

The framework below is an editorial framework proposed by this article. It is not the UNIRANKS methodology and does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions. It combines Sipos's (2026) outcome hierarchy with the distinction between output, outcome and impact indicators that Corazza and colleagues (2024) developed with stakeholders of one European University Alliance through a year-long interventionist study. In their framework, output indicators capture direct short-term effects, outcome indicators capture medium-term effects, and impact indicators capture longer-term change attributable to the activity.

Editorial framework: five levels of partnership evidence
LevelQuestionTypical evidenceCaution
1. ExistenceIs there a formal basis for cooperation?Agreement text, dates, scopeSays nothing about activity
2. ActivityWhat has actually been done?Courses run, mobility windows used, joint projectsCounts without denominators can mislead
3. ParticipationWho takes part, relative to who could?Participants by eligible population, discipline and backgroundDefinitions of "involvement" vary
4. Embedding and assuranceWould it survive the end of a grant? Is it quality assured and recognized?Catalog entries, recognized credits, continuing staff, recurrent budget, external reviewLegal status alone does not prove sustainability
5. OutcomesWhat changed for participants and institutions?Completion, credit recognition, staff development, documented institutional changeAttribution is difficult; avoid causal claims without suitable designs

Equity runs across all five levels: at each one, ask who decides, who pays and who benefits.

Our interpretation

Taken together, the sources suggest that the most informative evidence about a partnership is usually the least visible. Degree completions, recognized credits, co-supervised theses and recurrent budgets are harder to display than a map of partners, but they are what distinguishes cooperation that has changed how institutions work from cooperation that exists mainly on paper. The European Universities evidence also suggests that even substantial investment produces uneven embedding, and that the period of active funding is not a reliable guide to what will last.

We also read the evidence as a caution against treating partnerships as automatically beneficial. A partnership in which one institution controls funds and priorities, or in which only a small, well-resourced minority of students can participate, may be active and still fall short on access and fairness. Duration matters, but only when it reflects sustained activity rather than renewed paperwork.

Practical steps for evaluators, universities and prospective students

  1. Evaluators: ask for activity data for each partnership, not a total number of agreements, and require a stated denominator for every participation figure.
  2. Evaluators: for any joint or double degree, ask which external quality assurance procedure was used, by which agency, and where the award is recognized.
  3. Universities: review dormant agreements periodically and report active partnerships separately from signed ones.
  4. Universities: define outcome indicators when a partnership is designed, distinguishing outputs from participant and institutional outcomes.
  5. Universities: document governance and budget roles between partners, especially in partnerships across very different resource levels.
  6. Prospective students: before choosing a joint or double degree, ask how many students completed it in recent cohorts, how credits are transferred, and how the final award is recognized where you intend to work or study next.

Limitations

This article draws on five peer-reviewed sources, all read in full (none from abstracts only), and on official documents from the European Commission, EHEA ministers, EQAR, ENIC-NARIC and the UNESCO Global Convention text. The evidence is concentrated in Europe, especially the European Universities Initiative, and in one north-south case study; findings may not transfer to other systems. The Commission's outcomes report relies largely on self-reported monitoring data collected in 2023. Two of the peer-reviewed studies are small qualitative studies, and one is a single-alliance interventionist study. Our description of the European Approach relies on a 2019 EQAR presentation because EQAR's knowledge-base pages could not be opened during this review; national implementation may have changed since then. Knight's definitions date from 2011 and are used as a conceptual reference. None of the sources supports causal claims about the effect of partnerships on student or institutional outcomes.

Related reading on UNIRANKS

This article is part of our Internationalization & Diversity research. For the wider evaluation framework, see How Should Universities Measure Internationalization? For research collaboration as a networking practice, see The Power of Networking in Research.

Editorial disclosure

UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes an Internationalization & Diversity dimension. This article reviews independent research on whether international university partnerships deliver measurable results. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.

Research References

  1. Charret, A., & Chankseliani, M. (2023). The process of building European university alliances: a rhizomatic analysis of the European Universities Initiative. Higher Education, 86(1), 21-44. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-022-00898-6 (verified 21 November 2026)
  2. Corazza, L., Marengo, F., Torchia, D., et al. (2024). Developing a societal impact evaluation framework for sustainable European University Alliances. Scientific Reports, 14(1), 13052. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-63933-9 (verified 21 November 2026)
  3. Knight, J. (2011). Doubts and Dilemmas with Double Degree Programs. RUSC. Universities and Knowledge Society Journal, 8(2), 135. https://doi.org/10.7238/rusc.v8i2.1067 (verified 21 November 2026)
  4. Luthuli, S., Daniel, M., & Corbin, J. H. (2024). Power imbalances and equity in the day-to-day functioning of a north plus multi-south higher education institutions partnership: a case study. International Journal for Equity in Health, 23(1), 59. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12939-024-02139-x (verified 21 November 2026)
  5. Sipos, N. (2026). From Temporary Programme to European Infrastructure? Funding Dependence, Institutional Resilience and the Future of European University Alliances. Higher Education Policy, advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41307-026-00487-7 (verified 21 November 2026)

Sources

Share this article