Universities should measure internationalization as a process with purposes, not as a headcount. A credible evaluation asks what the institution is trying to achieve, which students and staff can actually take part, and what changes as a result. That means looking beyond the share of international students or the number of signed agreements to evidence across six connected areas: international enrollment, workforce composition, mobility, cross-border cooperation, research collaboration and support infrastructure. Each area needs input, activity and outcome evidence, read against the institution's size, mission and national context. Composite scores can summarize these signals, but they cannot replace them.
What does internationalization mean in higher education?
The most widely used starting point is Jane Knight's process definition. As quoted in a 2015 study for the European Parliament's Committee on Culture and Education, internationalization is "the process of integrating an international, intercultural, or global dimension into the purpose, functions or delivery of post-secondary education" (Knight, 2008, as cited by de Wit, Hunter, Howard and Egron-Polak, 2015, p. 45). The definition is deliberately neutral: it describes integration across an institution's purpose and functions rather than a list of activities or a target number.
The same European Parliament study, written by researchers from the Centre for Higher Education Internationalisation, the European Association for International Education and the International Association of Universities (IAU), proposed an extension after a Delphi panel exercise. Its revised wording describes internationalization as an intentional process and adds two purposes: "to enhance the quality of education and research for all students and staff" and "to make a meaningful contribution to society" (p. 29). The authors state that the revision reflects awareness that internationalization should become more inclusive and less elitist, and that it is a means to enhance quality rather than a goal in itself.
Internationalization abroad and at home
The literature commonly separates internationalization abroad (student, staff, program and provider mobility across borders) from internationalization at home. The European Parliament study reports that the "Internationalisation at Home" movement emerged in Europe in 1999 as a reaction to the strong focus on mobility, with the goal of giving an international dimension to the large majority of students who do not go abroad (p. 49). The current definition it cites, from Beelen and Jones (2015), is "the purposeful integration of international and intercultural dimensions into the formal and informal curriculum for all students within domestic learning environments." The study adds that such activity can take place with only local students, who bring their own diverse backgrounds.
Comprehensive internationalization
A third concept, comprehensive internationalization, is usually attributed to John Hudzik. The European Parliament study quotes his definition as "a commitment, confirmed through action, to infuse international and comparative perspectives throughout the teaching, research and service missions of higher education" (p. 44). The study also observes that in many universities that describe themselves as international, practice does not always match this rhetoric and is often a collection of fragmented activities rather than an institution-wide process.
More recent scholarship adds a critical dimension. In a 2022 conceptual article, Hans de Wit and Elspeth Jones argue that internationalization "continues to both reflect and exacerbate the inequalities in global societies," that study abroad tends to remain the preserve of a relatively wealthy group, and that strategies centered on mobility will produce unequal access, opportunity and outcomes. They call for a move from a Western, competitive paradigm toward a global cooperative strategy. For evaluation, the implication is that participation and distribution matter as much as volume.
Why counting activities is not the same as evaluating them
The 2015 European Parliament study lists ten key developments in internationalization. They include the growth of institutional strategies with a risk of "focus on quantitative results only," rising numbers with a "challenge of quantity versus quality," and a lack of sufficient data for comparative analysis and decision-making (p. 27). The study also notes that the discourse within internationalization is shifting from input and output to outcomes (p. 44).
Institutions have not ignored measurement. The 6th IAU Global Survey, an online institutional questionnaire answered by 722 higher education institutions in 110 countries and territories between January and June 2023, reports that 79% of respondents have defined targets and benchmarks for their internationalization strategy and 74% have a monitoring and evaluation framework. Only 54% have allocated a specific budget, and only 51% have defined international, intercultural or global learning outcomes or graduate capabilities, although that share rose from 38% in the previous survey (Marinoni and Pina Cardona, 2024). These are self-reported institutional answers, and the authors note that Europe and Latin America and the Caribbean are overrepresented while North America and Asia and Pacific are underrepresented, so the figures describe respondents rather than all universities.
The gap between monitoring frameworks and defined learning outcomes is the central measurement problem. A university can track many activities without stating what students or staff should gain from them. Qualitative research points the same way: a case study of two Chinese universities by Zheng and Wu (2022) reports a gap between national ambitions for internationalizing the humanities and social sciences and local institutional realities (abstract only read).
Dedicated review tools also exist. The European Parliament study describes several, including the Internationalisation Quality Review Process developed with the OECD, the German Rectors' Conference audit, the IAU Internationalisation Strategies Advisory Service, the Nuffic Mapping Internationalisation tool, and the Certificate for Quality in Internationalisation piloted by the European Consortium for Accreditation (pp. 55 to 56). Their common feature is that they review internationalization against the institution's own goals and quality processes rather than reducing it to a single figure.
The six areas most internationalization claims rest on
Most public claims about an "international university" draw on six areas. This overview treats each briefly; the companion articles in this series examine them in depth.
- International enrollment. Definitions shape the numbers. The OECD defines international students as those who completed their prior education in a different country and do not reside permanently in the host country, and it notes that foreign students, identified by citizenship, may be used as a proxy when data on international students are unavailable. A citizenship-based count and a prior-education-based count can describe different populations. The companion article on international student diversity explains why enrollment numbers are not enough.
- Workforce composition. International staff numbers say little about policy or integration. In the IAU survey, most institutions treat international experience in recruitment and promotion as at most an asset rather than a requirement, and it is required at only a small minority. A companion article examines how to measure international faculty diversity.
- Mobility. Outgoing credit-seeking student mobility (exchanges) was the activity most often named as a priority in the IAU survey, by 44% of respondents. The European Parliament study warns that an overly heavy focus on mobility serves only a small elite unless it is integrated into the curriculum (p. 282). A companion article examines how to measure international student mobility.
- Cross-border cooperation. In the IAU survey, 63% of respondents offer joint degrees or dual, double or multiple degrees. Whether an agreement produces teaching, mobility or joint work is a separate question, examined in the companion article on whether international partnerships deliver meaningful results.
- Research collaboration. International research collaboration and outputs were a priority for 39% of IAU respondents, and were named the most important activity by 65% of respondents in Sub-Saharan Africa. In this context, collaboration is evidence of international engagement, not a measure of research quality or of the student experience. Research performance is a separate dimension, covered in the Academic & Research Performance research section.
- Support infrastructure. According to the IAU survey, 92% of respondents have dedicated offices or teams overseeing their internationalization strategy. The existence of an office does not show that services are accessible, used or effective; separate articles in this series cover what support universities should provide international students and how to measure multicultural inclusion.
The limits of composite internationalization indicators
Composite indicators combine several measures into one score. The OECD and the European Commission's Joint Research Centre, in their Handbook on Constructing Composite Indicators (2008), acknowledge that composites can summarize complex realities and ease communication. They also list the risks: composites may send misleading messages if poorly constructed or misinterpreted, may invite simplistic conclusions, may disguise serious failings in some dimensions, and may lead to inappropriate decisions if dimensions that are difficult to measure are ignored (p. 13). The handbook states that, whichever method is used, "weights are essentially value judgements," and it advises checking whether an indicator depends on size-related factors and scaling it accordingly.
Applied to internationalization, four problems recur:
- Weighting. How much a mobility rate counts relative to a staff ratio is a choice about values, not a finding. Two reasonable weighting schemes can order the same institutions differently.
- Denominators. A share of international students depends on who counts as international (citizenship or prior education), who counts as a student (degree-seeking or short-term exchange) and which level is included. Without the denominator, a percentage cannot be compared.
- Size effects. Absolute counts of agreements, exchanges or co-authored papers grow with institutional size, while ratios at small institutions can swing sharply from year to year because of a handful of people.
- Gaming and displacement. When a number becomes a target, institutions can raise it without changing what it was meant to signal, for example by signing agreements that are never activated. The European Parliament study's warning about a focus on quantitative results only (p. 27) describes this risk at a general level.
Why large, specialized and smaller universities differ
Context changes what internationalization looks like, and the research reviewed here shows this at several levels.
National policy and rationale. A content analysis of 366 policy documents from 27 countries by Kapfudzaruwa (2025) found socio-economic rationales dominant in most of the sampled countries, but expressed differently in the global north and south according to national priorities, with political rationales becoming more important. The author notes that the country selection excluded some regions, including Eastern Europe and the Middle East and North Africa.
Resources and reciprocity. Moshtari and Safarpour (2024), drawing on a literature and document review and 10 interviews with academics in low-income East African countries, identified 12 challenges in four categories. They include a lack of clear policies, inefficient organizational structures, financial and infrastructure problems, weaknesses in language and other competences, cultural differences, non-reciprocal relationships and brain drain. The IAU survey reports a related regional pattern: in Sub-Saharan Africa, 56% of respondents said they have very little international research, mainly conducted by individual researchers.
Language, discipline and law. In a survey of 76 academic staff at six universities in Cyprus, Soule (2025) found that STEM staff tended to equate internationalization at home with English-medium instruction and materials, while non-STEM staff described broader intercultural practices. Senior academics were more likely to implement structurally supported activities. The study also reports that public universities in Cyprus are legally restricted from offering undergraduate instruction in English. The author notes the small sample and reliance on self-reported perceptions.
Regional priorities. The IAU survey found no single priority activity worldwide. In North America, 74% of respondents named incoming degree-seeking recruitment as the most important activity; in Latin America and the Caribbean, 65% named outgoing exchanges; in Sub-Saharan Africa, 65% named international research collaboration. Whitsed and colleagues (2024) report that curriculum internationalization in Latin American universities has traditionally focused almost solely on student mobility, and that it is approached very differently across national, institutional and disciplinary contexts (abstract only read).
For institutional type, the implication is practical. A large comprehensive university may have many partnerships and a broad international enrollment, but participation may be concentrated in a few faculties. A specialized institution may be deeply international in one field and limited elsewhere, which is a matter of mission rather than weakness. A small university may have few mobile students in absolute terms but a high participation rate, or strong internationalization at home with little mobility at all.
An editorial framework for evaluating internationalization claims
The table below is an editorial framework proposed by this article to help readers test claims. It is not the UNIRANKS methodology and does not describe how UNIRANKS evaluates institutions. For reference, UNIRANKS describes its Internationalization & Diversity dimension as examining international students and faculty, global partnerships, research collaboration, mobility programs, international student support, multicultural engagement and international academic visibility.
| Dimension | Input evidence | Activity evidence | Outcome evidence | Typical data source | Common pitfall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| International enrollment | Recruitment policy, scholarships, admission routes | Enrolled international students by level, program and country of prior education | Retention, completion and progression compared with domestic students | Student records; national statistics returns | Unstated definition (citizenship or prior education); one dominant source country hidden in a total |
| Workforce composition | Recruitment and promotion criteria, visa and relocation support | Staff by citizenship, place of qualification and contract type | Retention and career progression of international staff | Human resources records; staff surveys | Counting short visiting appointments as permanent staff |
| Student and staff mobility | Funding, credit recognition rules, eligibility | Participants as a share of the eligible population, by duration and type | Credit recognized, learning gains, equity of participation | Mobility office records; program reports | Reporting totals without denominators or participant profile |
| Partnerships and cross-border cooperation | Signed agreements, joint and double degree approvals | Active agreements with exchanges, joint teaching or projects in the last cycle | Graduates of joint programs, sustained joint work, quality assurance results | Agreement registers; program reviews; accreditation reports | Counting dormant agreements |
| Research collaboration | International grants, visiting researcher schemes | Joint projects and co-authored outputs | Durable partnerships and shared infrastructure | Research office data; funder reports | Treating co-authorship counts as a measure of research quality |
| Internationalization at home and curriculum | Defined international or intercultural learning outcomes | Courses with international content, virtual exchange, intercultural activities | Assessed learning outcomes for all students, not only mobile ones | Curriculum documents; assessment data; student surveys | Equating English-medium instruction with internationalization |
| Support infrastructure | Staffed offices, budget, published services | Service use, response times, orientation coverage | Satisfaction and complaint resolution, outcomes of supported students | Service logs; student surveys; complaint records | Listing services that exist without evidence that they are accessible or used |
Three reading rules make the framework usable. First, outcome evidence carries more weight than input evidence, but it is also the hardest to collect, so its absence should be stated rather than filled with proxies. Second, every share needs its denominator and every count needs its trend. Third, comparisons are meaningful only between institutions of similar size, mission and national context.
Our interpretation
Taken together, the sources point to a consistent conclusion. Established definitions describe internationalization as an intentional process intended to improve education and research for all students and staff, yet the most visible indicators measure the minority who move and the agreements that are signed. Institutions report widespread monitoring frameworks, but only about half of IAU respondents have defined what international learning should produce. The research on East Africa, Cyprus, Latin America and national policy documents shows that resources, language law, discipline and national rationale shape internationalization so strongly that a single cross-national number is likely to reflect context as much as institutional effort. These studies are mostly qualitative or survey-based and describe associations and perceptions, not causal effects, so they support caution in interpretation rather than any specific score.
Practical steps for universities and evaluators
- State the purpose first. Write down what internationalization is meant to achieve for students, staff, research and society, using the extended definition as a check.
- Define every number. Publish the definition and denominator behind each figure: who is counted as international, which levels are included and which year the data cover.
- Report participation, not only volume. Express mobility and international activity as a share of eligible students and staff, broken down by faculty and, where privacy allows, by student background.
- Separate active from signed partnerships. Report how many agreements produced exchanges, joint teaching or joint projects in the last cycle.
- Define and assess international learning outcomes. Include internationalization at home so that evidence covers students who never travel.
- Read composite scores as summaries. Ask for the weights, the components and the effect of size before drawing conclusions from any combined figure.
- Compare like with like. Benchmark against institutions with a similar size, mission, language setting and national policy framework.
Limitations
This article draws on six peer-reviewed sources. Four were read in full as open-access texts (de Wit and Jones, 2022; Moshtari and Safarpour, 2024; Kapfudzaruwa, 2025; Soule, 2025) and two were read from abstracts only (Zheng and Wu, 2022; Whitsed and colleagues, 2024), so claims from those two are limited to what their abstracts state. Knight's original 2004 article and the original texts by Hudzik and by Beelen and Jones were not accessible during this review; their definitions are quoted as reproduced in the 2015 European Parliament study. The IAU figures are institutional self-reports from an unevenly distributed sample, and the European Parliament study, published in 2015, reflects the policy context of that time. The studies on context cover specific countries and regions and should not be generalized to all higher education systems.
Related reading on UNIRANKS
This article introduces the Internationalization & Diversity research series. The companion articles in the series, listed below this article, look in more detail at international student diversity, international faculty diversity, international partnerships, international student mobility, international student support and multicultural inclusion.
Editorial disclosure
UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes an Internationalization & Diversity dimension. This article reviews independent research on how universities can define and evaluate internationalization. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.
Research References
- de Wit, H., & Jones, E. (2022). A New View of Internationalization: From a Western, Competitive Paradigm to a Global Cooperative Strategy. Journal of Higher Education Policy And Leadership Studies, 3(1), 142-152. https://doi.org/10.52547/johepal.3.1.142 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Kapfudzaruwa, F. (2025). Internationalization of Higher Education and Emerging National Rationales: Comparative Analysis of the Global North and South. Higher Education Policy, 38(3), 493-522. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41307-024-00358-z (verified 21 November 2026)
- Moshtari, M., & Safarpour, A. (2024). Challenges and strategies for the internationalization of higher education in low-income East African countries. Higher Education, 87(1), 89-109. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-023-00994-1 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Soule, M. V. (2025). Contextualizing Internationalization at Home: academic perspectives from Cypriot higher education in a changing global landscape. Frontiers in Education, 10, 1657401. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2025.1657401 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Whitsed, C., Cassol, C. C., Leask, B., et al. (2024). Disrupting internationalisation of the curriculum in Latin America. Higher Education, 88(3), 1145-1163. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-023-01163-0 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Zheng, J., & Wu, H. (2022). Translating rhetoric into reality: using the internationalization of humanities and social sciences in Chinese universities as the case. Higher Education, 84(3), 611-628. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-021-00791-8 (verified 21 November 2026)
Sources
- de Wit, H., Hunter, F., Howard, L., & Egron-Polak, E. (2015). Internationalisation of Higher Education. Study requested by the Committee on Culture and Education. European Parliament, Policy Department B: Structural and Cohesion Policies. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2015/540370/IPOL_STU(2015)540370_EN.pdf (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Marinoni, G., & Pina Cardona, S. B. (2024). Internationalization of Higher Education: Current Trends and Future Scenarios. 6th IAU Global Survey Report, Executive Summary. International Association of Universities. https://iau.global/s/2024_internationalization_survey_-_executive_summary.pdf (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Handbook on Constructing Composite Indicators: Methodology and User Guide (2008). OECD and European Commission Joint Research Centre. https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/handbook-on-constructing-composite-indicators-methodology-and-user-guide_9789264043466-en.html (accessed 21 November 2026)
- International student mobility (indicator definition). OECD. https://www.oecd.org/en/data/indicators/international-student-mobility.html (accessed 21 November 2026)
