How Should Universities Measure International Student Mobility?

Share

Universities should measure international student mobility as a share of a clearly defined eligible population, not as a headcount of exchange places or agreements. A credible measure separates incoming from outgoing students and credit mobility from degree mobility, reports short-term and blended formats separately from semester stays, and states the denominator appropriate to the indicator, such as a graduating cohort for cumulative mobility participation or the eligible enrolled population for annual mobility rates. It then tests whether the credits earned abroad were recognized, whether participants progressed on time, and whether students from disadvantaged backgrounds took part. An offer of opportunities is not evidence of participation, and participation alone is not evidence of learning or career benefit.

Why opportunity and participation are different things

Many institutional statements describe mobility in terms of supply: the number of partner universities, exchange agreements or funded places. These figures describe what a university makes available. They say nothing about how many students actually went abroad, who those students were, or what happened to their studies afterwards. The official description of the UNIRANKS Internationalization & Diversity dimension makes the same distinction in general terms, referring to both "the international composition of the university and the practical opportunities available for students and academics to participate in global education." Practical opportunity, in a measurement sense, is better shown by uptake among eligible students than by the length of a partner list. Partnerships themselves are discussed in our article on whether international university partnerships deliver meaningful results.

The research on who studies abroad shows why the gap matters. A 2025 study by Granato and Schnepf, using administrative data on 46,096 students in 102 degree programs at the University of Bologna between 2010 and 2019, found that 66% of graduates had parents with lower levels of education, but only 55.4% of Erasmus applicants did. The authors attribute about 90% of the socioeconomic gap in Erasmus participation to the application stage, with eligibility checks and selection on prior performance contributing much less. In other words, the places existed; disadvantaged students were far less likely to apply for them.

Which kinds of mobility should be counted separately?

Incoming and outgoing mobility

Incoming students (those who arrive from other countries) and outgoing students (a university's own students who go abroad) answer different questions. Incoming numbers describe the international composition of classrooms; outgoing numbers describe the opportunities a university's own students take up. Adding them together into one "mobility" figure hides both. Incoming degree-seeking students are the subject of a companion article in this series on international student diversity; this article concentrates on mobility as an experience that students undertake during their studies.

Credit mobility and degree mobility

Eurostat, the statistical office of the European Union, distinguishes degree-mobile students, who enroll abroad with the intention of graduating there, from credit-mobile students, who spend a temporary period of study or traineeship abroad while enrolled at a home institution, usually to gain academic credit. Its methodology for credit-mobile graduates excludes mobility that the home institution does not recognize (so-called bridge mobility). For a university, credit mobility is the variable it most directly controls, because it designs the curriculum windows, partner agreements and recognition rules that make a stay abroad possible.

Semester exchanges, short stays and blended formats

The Council of the European Union's Recommendation of 13 May 2024, "Europe on the Move", defines which higher education stays count toward the EU learning mobility target: outgoing degree mobility; outgoing credit mobility of at least three months or 15 ECTS credits, including traineeships; and shorter outgoing mobility of less than three months and at least three ECTS credits. These stays may be fully physical or blended, meaning they combine a virtual and a physical component. A purely virtual activity, with no physical stay abroad, is therefore not counted under that target definition, although the Recommendation supports blended and short-term formats as a way to widen participation.

The evidence base for short and virtual formats is still thin. A 2024 study by Higgins in the Journal of International Students reported gains in intercultural communication and English skills after an eight-week virtual exchange, but its sample was ten undergraduates from Thailand and Japan, assessed before and after the program. Results of that kind are useful for program design; they cannot show that a format produces the same outcomes as a semester abroad. A sound measure therefore reports short, blended and virtual activities in their own categories rather than merging them with semester stays.

Choosing the denominator: graduating cohort or enrolled students?

The denominator is the most consequential choice in any mobility rate. The Council Recommendation states that the higher education target "is calculated at graduate level for graduates participating in learning mobility at least once during their studies," and sets the ambition that at least 23% of higher education graduates should have a learning mobility experience abroad by 2030, up from the 20% target first set in the Bologna Process in 2009. The vocational target in the same text uses a different construction: mobile learners in a calendar year as a proportion of a cohort of VET graduates in the same year.

A cohort-based rate asks a student-centered question: of the people who completed a degree, how many had at least one mobility experience? An annual rate based on all enrolled students asks an operational question: how many students were abroad this year? The two can differ by a large factor. As purely hypothetical arithmetic, a university with 15,000 enrolled students, 3,000 graduates a year and 600 outgoing students a year would report 4% if it divided by enrollment. In a steady state where each mobile student goes abroad once and later graduates, about 600 of each year's 3,000 graduates would have been abroad, a cohort rate of 20%. Neither number is wrong, but they are not comparable, and a report that does not state which one it uses cannot be interpreted.

The eligible population also matters. Programs that are fully online, part-time, or designed for working adults may have very different structural chances of physical mobility. Reporting rates by level and field, and stating which students are excluded from the base, is more informative than a single institutional figure.

Mobility metrics: definition, denominator, what each shows and the main pitfall (editorial summary)
MetricDefinitionDenominatorWhat it showsMain pitfall
Cohort mobility rateGraduates with at least one recognized mobility experience during their studiesAll graduates of the cohort (by level and field)How widely mobility reaches students by the end of a degreeStudents counted twice if several stays are not deduplicated; definition of a qualifying stay must be stated
Annual outgoing rateStudents abroad for credit in a given yearEnrolled students that yearCurrent program activity and capacityLooks small beside cohort rates; not comparable with them
Incoming exchange countStudents from partner institutions hosted for creditUsually none, or total enrollmentReciprocity and the international mix of classesReported together with outgoing figures, it hides imbalance
Uptake of available placesPlaces filled, divided by places offeredPlaces offeredWhether opportunities are usedHigh uptake of very few places can still mean low participation
Application rate by groupApplicants as a share of eligible students, by parental education, income or other backgroundEligible students in each groupWhere unequal participation beginsRequires background data that many universities do not collect consistently
Recognition rateCredits recognized at home, divided by credits agreed before departureCredits in learning agreementsWhether mobility is integrated into the degreeMeasuring credits awarded but not whether they count toward the degree
Progression after mobilityTime to degree and completion of participants compared with similar non-participantsParticipants and a comparison groupWhether mobility delays or disrupts studyParticipants are not a random group, so simple comparisons mislead
Duration mixShare of stays that are short (under three months), semester-length or longerAll mobility episodesThe distribution of mobility experiences by duration and formatShort formats can raise headline rates; duration alone does not show what students learned

Who participates, and why does it matter for measurement?

Social selectivity in study abroad is one of the most consistently documented patterns in this field. In a 2021 overview introducing a special issue of Higher Education, Netz summarizes research showing that the likelihood of studying abroad depends on personality traits, benefit expectations, socio-demographic characteristics including social origin, prior academic performance and language skills, as well as contextual factors such as parents and peers, field of study, the design of study programs and the availability of funding. An earlier German study by Lörz, Netz and Quast (2016), which we read in abstract only, reported that students from underprivileged families less often form an intention to study abroad, partly because of earlier educational experiences, and also because of higher sensitivity to costs and lower expected benefits.

The Bologna data in Granato and Schnepf add an institutional dimension. About 22% of students with higher-educated parents applied for Erasmus, compared with 14% of students with lower-educated parents. The authors estimate that 28% of the variation in applications lay between degree courses, and that students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds tended to enroll in courses with lower overall application rates. They also note that their data come from one university, which limits generalization, and that their models explain only about a quarter of the socioeconomic gap in applications.

Policy has started to treat this as a measurement problem. The 2024 Council Recommendation asks Member States to aspire to a share of at least 20% of people with fewer opportunities among all learners benefiting from learning mobility abroad by 2027, estimated for now from Erasmus+ and European Solidarity Corps data, which the text says "by no means cover all types of learning mobility abroad." It invites the European Commission to propose a data collection methodology by 2026. The Eurydice Mobility Scoreboard, which monitors top-level policy rather than institutional practice, tracks six indicator areas, including portability of grants and loans, support for disadvantaged learners and recognition of learning outcomes through ECTS; its 2022/2023 background report covers all 27 EU Member States. Financial accessibility is therefore part of the measurement, not a side issue: a mobility rate that rises only among students who can self-fund says something different from one that rises across income groups.

Credit recognition and academic progression

Recognition determines whether a stay abroad is part of a student's degree or an interruption of it. Eurostat's exclusion of unrecognized bridge mobility from credit-mobility statistics reflects this, and the Council Recommendation calls for automatic mutual recognition of the outcomes of learning periods abroad, including virtual and blended learning. For an institution, the most direct indicator is the proportion of credits agreed in advance that were recognized on return, together with the proportion of participants whose time to degree was extended. We did not find a peer-reviewed source that we could open in full today giving a reliable cross-national recognition rate, so this article does not cite one. Universities can, however, calculate their own rate from learning agreements and transcripts.

What does the research show about outcomes?

Claims that study abroad "improves employability" are common in institutional material. The evidence is more qualified.

  • Wages. Netz and Cordua (2021) reviewed 19 quantitative studies of studying abroad and graduates' wages. Unadjusted wage differences in many studies ranged between 2% and 16%; after accounting for the fact that students who go abroad differ from those who do not, effect estimates mostly ranged between −5% and 12%. The authors conclude that studying abroad has a moderate positive effect on early-career wages in various settings, that the effect varies by group, employment context and type of stay, and that matching methods may still overestimate the causal effect because they cannot capture unobserved selection.
  • Employment and further study. Using propensity score matching on graduate survey data, d'Hombres and Schnepf (2021) found that Italian graduates with mobility experience were 6.3 percentage points more likely to be employed about one year after graduation and 3.6 points four years after; in the UK the difference was 2.3 points, and at four years it was no longer statistically significant. Mobility was also associated with an 8 percentage point higher uptake of postgraduate study in Italy but not in the UK. The authors note that their estimates depend on the assumption that no relevant variable was omitted.
  • Who benefits. Netz and Grüttner (2021), using the 2005 DZHW Graduate Panel in Germany, found that graduates from a high social origin benefited slightly more in labor income over the first ten years of their careers. Netz's 2021 overview describes the evidence on differences by social origin as mixed across countries and outcomes, and characterizes the effects of studying abroad as moderate and often confined to particular groups, contexts and types of stay.
  • Research gaps. A systematic review by Roy, Newman, Ellenberger and Pyman (2019), read in abstract only, identified employment and career outcomes as under-researched in the literature on short-term mobility programs. Netz (2021) calls for long-running panel data and experimental designs to better approximate causal effects.

Learning outcomes, such as language proficiency, intercultural competence and personality development, are listed by Netz (2021) among the domains that impact studies have examined. For institutions, the practical lesson is that outcomes need to be measured with pre-defined learning goals and, where possible, comparison groups, rather than inferred from participation.

Duration, partner quality and data comparability

Duration is often missing from the evidence. Of the 19 studies in the Netz and Cordua review, 12 did not report the exact duration of the stays they examined; the others covered stays from three weeks to one year. A mobility measure that does not record duration cannot tell whether growth comes from semester exchanges or from one-week visits. Duration is descriptive, however: a longer stay is not by itself evidence of educational quality, which has to be judged against stated learning goals and outcome evidence.

Partner quality matters for whether students can take courses that fit their degree, but the number of partners is not a measure of quality. Indicators such as the share of agreements that actually sent or received students in recent years are discussed in our partnerships article.

Comparability across systems is limited. Eurostat notes that the country of origin for mobility data should in principle be the country of prior secondary education, but that countries may use prior residence, citizenship or another concept. It also reports approximately 418,400 credit-mobile graduates from the EU in 2024 and describes that figure as likely to be an underestimate because coverage is incomplete. The Council Recommendation itself asks the Commission to propose an updated methodology by 2026 for measuring the share of graduates with a learning mobility experience. Cross-country comparisons of mobility rates should be read with these caveats.

An editorial framework for evaluating mobility claims

The following framework is proposed by this article as an editorial tool. It is not the UNIRANKS methodology and does not describe how UNIRANKS evaluates institutions.

  1. Definition: Is it clear which stays count (degree, credit, short-term, blended, virtual), with minimum duration or credits stated?
  2. Denominator: Is the rate based on a graduating cohort or on annual enrollment, and which students are excluded from the eligible base?
  3. Direction: Are incoming and outgoing students reported separately?
  4. Participation, not supply: Is uptake reported alongside the number of agreements or places?
  5. Equity: Are application and participation rates broken down by background, and is financial support described?
  6. Academic integration: Are recognition rates and time to degree reported for participants?
  7. Outcomes: Are learning outcomes measured against stated goals, and are employment claims attributed to studies that account for selection?
  8. Data quality: Are sources, years and definitions stated so that figures can be compared over time?

Our interpretation

The studies reviewed here point in one direction: the meaningful unit of measurement is the student, not the agreement. The Bologna evidence suggests that inequality in mobility arises mostly before selection, at the point where students decide whether to apply, and differs by degree course. If that pattern holds elsewhere, a university that reports only total participants could expand mobility while widening the gap between groups. Measures that track applications by background and by program are therefore more informative than a single rate.

The outcome research supports modest, context-dependent claims, not general ones. A university can reasonably say that studies in several European countries have associated mobility with moderate early-career benefits; it cannot reasonably say that its own program causes better employment without evidence that accounts for who chose to participate. Short and blended formats may widen access, as the Council text intends, but they should not be counted as if they were equivalent to a semester abroad until outcome data support that.

Practical steps for universities and evaluators

  • Publish a cohort mobility rate by level and field, with the qualifying definition (for example, at least three months or 15 ECTS, or short stays of at least three ECTS) and the size of the denominator.
  • Report short-term, blended and virtual activities in separate categories, with their typical duration.
  • Track applications as well as participation, by parental education or another available background measure, and examine which degree programs have low application rates.
  • Calculate a recognition rate from learning agreements and transcripts, and compare time to degree for participants with similar non-participants.
  • Describe the financial support available, including whether national or institutional grants can be used abroad. Wider support services for international students are discussed in our article on what support universities should provide international students.
  • Evaluators should ask for the denominator and definition before comparing any two mobility figures, and treat employability claims without a cited study as unverified.

Limitations

This article draws on eight peer-reviewed references. Six were read in full text or in substantial open-access sections (Granato and Schnepf 2025; Netz and Cordua 2021; Higgins 2024; d'Hombres and Schnepf 2021; Netz and Grüttner 2021; Netz 2021), and two from abstracts only (Lörz, Netz and Quast 2016; Roy, Newman, Ellenberger and Pyman 2019). Netz (2021) is an editorial overview introducing a journal special issue rather than an empirical study. Most of the outcome evidence comes from European countries, especially Germany and Italy, and from graduates who studied in the 2000s and 2010s, so it may not apply to other systems or to recent short-term formats. The social-selectivity study uses data from one university. Several relevant papers could not be opened through their DOI landing pages today and were excluded, including a 2024 study of Erasmus and time to degree. Official definitions are taken from European Union sources; we could not open the UNESCO Institute for Statistics glossary pages today, so its indicator definitions are not quoted.

Related reading on UNIRANKS

For the wider context, see the Internationalization & Diversity research hub, our overview of how universities should measure internationalization, and the student mobility section of Explore.

Editorial disclosure

UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes an Internationalization & Diversity dimension. This article reviews independent research on how universities can measure international student mobility. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.

Research References

  1. d'Hombres, B., & Schnepf, S. V. (2021). International mobility of students in Italy and the UK: does it pay off and for whom? Higher Education, 82(6), 1173-1194. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-020-00631-1 (verified 21 November 2026)
  2. Granato, S., & Schnepf, S. V. (2025). Why are lower socioeconomic background students underrepresented in Erasmus? A focus on the selection into mobility and degree course organization. Studies in Higher Education, 50(3), 638-652. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2024.2349963 (verified 21 November 2026)
  3. Higgins, J. (2024). Virtual bridges to global competence: Cultivating undergraduates' English communication and intercultural skills through online exchange. Journal of International Students, 14(4), 862-882. https://doi.org/10.32674/jis.v14i4.6545 (verified 21 November 2026)
  4. Lörz, M., Netz, N., & Quast, H. (2016). Why do students from underprivileged families less often intend to study abroad? Higher Education, 72(2), 153-174. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-015-9943-1 (verified 21 November 2026)
  5. Netz, N. (2021). Who benefits most from studying abroad? A conceptual and empirical overview. Higher Education, 82(6), 1049-1069. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-021-00760-1 (verified 21 November 2026)
  6. Netz, N., & Cordua, F. (2021). Does studying abroad influence graduates' wages? A literature review. Journal of International Students, 11(4), 768-789. https://doi.org/10.32674/jis.v11i4.4008 (verified 21 November 2026)
  7. Netz, N., & Grüttner, M. (2021). Does the effect of studying abroad on labour income vary by graduates' social origin? Evidence from Germany. Higher Education, 82(6), 1195-1217. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-020-00579-2 (verified 21 November 2026)
  8. Roy, A., Newman, A., Ellenberger, T., et al. (2019). Outcomes of international student mobility programs: a systematic review and agenda for future research. Studies in Higher Education, 44(9), 1630-1644. https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2018.1458222 (verified 21 November 2026)

Sources

Share this article