How Can Universities Measure International Faculty Diversity?

Share

Universities can measure international faculty diversity credibly only by stating which definition of "international" they use, reporting several definitions side by side, and pairing composition counts with evidence on contracts, careers, contributions and working conditions. A headcount of foreign nationals answers one narrow question: how many staff hold a passport from another country. It does not show whether those academics are on secure contracts, whether they progress, whether their teaching and service are recognized, or whether home-educated staff with deep international experience are counted at all. Peer-reviewed research from the UK, Thailand, Australia and Europe shows how much each of these gaps matters.

Why the definition of an "international" academic changes the count

There is no single agreed definition of an international academic. In a 2023 study of internationally mobile academics in Thailand, Alina Schartner, Tony Johnstone Young and Navaporn Snodin describe this group as a hard-to-define population and note, citing earlier work, that some countries apply citizenship or visa categories to decide who is international while others leave the decision to individual institutions. A 2022 review in Higher Education by Wenqin Shen, Xin Xu and Xiaona Wang likewise states that the definition of international academic mobility "bears ambiguities" and proposes a redefinition that integrates international student and faculty mobility, linked to the production, transfer and circulation of knowledge.

The choice of definition is not a technicality. The same department can look highly international or almost entirely local depending on whether staff are classified by passport, by country of birth, by where they earned their doctorate, or by where they have worked. Bruce Macfarlane and Li Huan Chen, in a 2026 conceptual paper, argue that nationality "is essentially an accident of birth" and is not a reliable indicator of international knowledge or reputation. They distinguish a descriptive "international faculty member" (someone holding a foreign passport) from the more evaluative "international academic", and they propose two categories that a passport count cannot see: "locals from abroad", foreign nationals whose work and networks are mainly local, and "cosmopolitans at home", home-born and home-educated scholars with strong international standing.

Other definitions appear in practice. Ming Cheng's 2026 study of Chinese international academics in England defines its population by birthplace and ethnicity: staff born outside the UK and of Chinese ethnicity. The European Commission's Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (MSCA) Postdoctoral Fellowships use residence rather than nationality. Their mobility rule states that applicants "must not have resided or carried out their main activity" in the host country for more than 12 months in the 36 months before the call deadline, and European Postdoctoral Fellowships are open to researchers of any nationality. Under that rule a citizen returning home after years abroad can count as mobile, while a long-resident foreign national may not.

Alternative definitions of an international academic: what each captures, what it misses, and how available the data usually are (editorial comparison)
DefinitionWhat it capturesWhat it missesTypical data availability
Nationality or citizenshipLegal status, often linked to immigration and employment rulesNaturalized staff, dual nationals, home citizens trained abroad; says nothing about international expertiseCommonly held in HR records; published nationally in some systems (the UK's official staff statistics cover nationality)
Country of birthMigration background across a careerStaff who moved as children and were educated locally; return migrantsLess often collected; sensitive personal data
Country of doctoral qualificationInternational academic training, including home nationals educated abroadForeign nationals who trained locally; quality and relevance of the trainingUsually in appointment files, rarely published in a comparable form
Prior employment countryProfessional experience in other academic systemsLength and depth of that experience; short research staysCVs only; rarely coded systematically
Recent residence (mobility rule)Recent cross-border moves, as in the MSCA 12-in-36-months ruleLong-term migrants and earlier career mobilityCollected by funders for eligibility, not by most universities
Visiting and short-term appointmentsFlows of people through a departmentWhether visits produce lasting teaching, supervision or curriculum changeOften recorded separately from core staff or not at all
International experience and esteemExamining, editorial, keynote and visiting roles abroad, as proposed by Macfarlane and ChenStaff early in their careers; depends on self-reported CV dataNot collected in official statistics; would require institutional design

Which staff are being counted: full-time, part-time and visiting

A second decision sits underneath the definition: whom to include. Macfarlane and Chen, citing earlier research, note that international faculty need to be distinguished from language teachers and from people with short-term or honorary affiliations. Counting a visiting scholar who spends two weeks on campus in the same way as a full-time lecturer inflates the figure without telling anyone how much international expertise is available to students across a year.

Official statistics show that this problem is structural. Eurostat's joint UOE data collection on education personnel defines academic staff as personnel at the tertiary level whose primary assignment is instruction and/or research, and it breaks the counts down by level, programme orientation, sex, age group, public or private institution, and employment status (part-time, full-time and full-time equivalent). Citizenship is not among those breakdowns. Eurostat does publish researchers by country of citizenship in a separate research and development dataset, but that population is researchers, not academic staff, and the unit is a headcount. In the 2023 figures for the higher education sector, 14 of the 27 EU member states have a published figure for researchers holding the reporting country's citizenship; Germany, France, the Netherlands and Sweden, among others, show only totals. The practical lesson is that no single official source combines citizenship, contract type and full-time equivalence for academic staff across Europe, so institutions that want that picture have to build it from their own records.

Recruitment and retention: what draws international academics and what keeps them

Research on motivations suggests that recruitment counts can mislead about intent. In 62 semi-structured interviews with foreign-born academics in the UK, Toma Pustelnikovaite (2021) argues that the availability of relatively good-quality employment shaped international academic mobility more than preferences for a particular country. The same abstract describes academics becoming "stuck": tracked into the host system while losing the credentials, experience and networks needed for another international move. A retention rate, on this reading, can reflect limited alternatives as much as satisfaction.

Jasvir Kaur Nachatar Singh's 2024 qualitative study of 26 international academics in Australian universities frames careers in terms of career capital: reasons for migrating, the teaching and research knowledge academics bring, and the social connections they build and rely on. Measures that stop at arrival miss whether that capital is used.

European survey evidence adds a career-stage dimension. Carolina Cañibano, Pablo D'Este, F. Javier Otamendi and Richard Woolley (2020), using the MORE survey of researchers in European universities, report that the profile of international mobility varies by career stage and that, for established mid-career researchers working abroad, career advancement benefits are associated with return mobility to the home country, benefits that may shrink if return is delayed. This is an association reported in the study's abstract, not proof that returning causes advancement, but it is relevant to the idea of brain circulation: outward and return moves can both be part of a healthy academic workforce, and a static snapshot of foreign nationals captures neither.

Contract security and precarity

Contract terms are where headcounts and lived experience diverge most sharply. In the Thailand study, 17 academics took part in three focus groups. Most were on short-term or rolling contracts, which participants experienced as precarious and linked to a perceived high staff turnover and weak retention of international academics. Immigration and work-permit renewal, which some had to repeat annually or every two years, created a feeling of impermanence. Among negative comments on work adjustment, the authors counted six on immigration and visas, six on salaries and job contracts and five on development and career progression. The authors identify a lack of secure status as a crucial challenge.

These findings come from one country and a small qualitative sample, so they show what can go wrong rather than how common it is. They do show why an international staff share reported without a breakdown by contract type can hide a workforce that is international mainly at its most insecure edge.

Research, teaching and hidden contributions

Composition figures also say nothing about what international academics are asked to do and whether it is recognized. Cheng's interviews with 41 Chinese international academics at four universities in England found that participants' language skills and cultural knowledge were sought for equality committees and for attracting and supporting Chinese international students, often without workload allocation for that labour. Cheng reports participants describing formal workloads above 100 percent and more than half performing extensive hidden labour, and links this to the concept of "cultural taxation".

In the Thailand study, participants described themselves as research active but attributed this mainly to individual effort rather than structured research support, and some reported that promotion criteria emphasized the number of publications over their quality. For measurement, this means that teaching, supervision, curriculum development and service by international staff need to be visible in workload and promotion data, not only research output. Research collaboration with international partners is a separate question covered elsewhere and is not a proxy for the quality of an academic's contribution.

Career progression and possible disadvantage

Career outcomes are where disadvantage, if it exists, becomes measurable. In Cheng's study, 35 of 41 participants (85 percent) had experienced or witnessed microaggressions; 25 reported promotion barriers, and 19 named lack of transparency in promotion as the main one. Cheng reports that institutional structures concentrated Chinese academics in junior, teaching-heavy positions, and that 24 participants (59 percent) had considered leaving academia or the UK. These are counts from a qualitative sample, not national rates, but they identify the data that would test such patterns at scale: grade distribution, promotion application and success rates, and exit rates by group.

Macfarlane and Chen raise a different career issue. They argue that appointment, promotion and tenure criteria in many systems reward local orientation even where institutional strategies speak of internationalization, and that opportunities such as sabbaticals may be less available to women, who are more likely to hold casual or part-time posts and carry caring responsibilities. They suggest auditing sabbaticals on equality grounds. Their paper is conceptual, so these are arguments supported by cited literature rather than new empirical findings.

Intercultural working environments

A diverse staff list does not establish an inclusive workplace. In the Thailand study, none of the participants had received cultural orientation before taking up their posts, even though such preparation was available to international students. Some reported a lack of mixing with local colleagues and not being invited to meetings or events, and very few were fluent in Thai while many meetings were not translated. In Cheng's study, 15 participants reported accent-based discrimination. Measures of inclusion for staff therefore need to look at access to governance and information, not only at nationality distribution. The companion article on measuring multicultural inclusion in universities discusses inclusion measures in more depth.

National context: employment law, immigration and language of instruction

Comparisons across countries need care because the rules that shape international hiring differ. The studies reviewed here describe annual or biennial work-permit renewal in Thailand, tenure arrangements that vary widely between higher education systems, and working environments in which the language of meetings and daily administration differs from the language many international staff speak. These differences are context, not a basis for advice: this article does not describe immigration or employment rules for any country. They matter for measurement because a lower international share in a system with restrictive permits or a national language of instruction is not comparable, on its own terms, with the share in an English-medium system with open recruitment. Macfarlane and Chen also report that some Chinese universities now publish the share of faculty with overseas experience or overseas doctorates, which shifts the count toward home nationals trained abroad, though they note that such figures still largely serve institutional marketing.

An editorial framework for measuring international faculty diversity

The framework below is an editorial proposal by this article. It is not the UNIRANKS methodology and does not describe how UNIRANKS evaluates institutions.

Editorial framework: five layers of evidence on international faculty diversity (not the UNIRANKS methodology)
LayerQuestionExample evidenceCommon pitfall
1. CompositionWho counts as international, under which definitions?Shares by citizenship, doctoral country and prior employment country, reported side by side, in headcount and full-time equivalentOne passport-based figure presented as the whole picture
2. Employment conditionsAre international staff on comparable terms?Contract type (open-ended, fixed-term, hourly, visiting) by group; contract lengthMixing visiting and short-term staff into core totals
3. CareersDo international staff progress and stay?Grade distribution, promotion applications and success rates, exits and reasons for leaving, by groupReading retention as satisfaction when alternatives may be limited
4. ContributionWhat do international staff do, and is it recognized?Teaching, supervision, curriculum and service roles; whether extra roles carry workload allocationCounting research output only
5. EnvironmentCan international staff participate fully?Pre-arrival and orientation support for staff, language access to meetings and documents, staff climate survey items, complaint handlingTreating a diverse staff list as evidence of inclusion

A sixth consideration cuts across all five layers: international experience among home staff. Following Macfarlane and Chen's argument, institutions can track whether locally educated staff have fair access to sabbaticals, visiting posts and international examining roles, so that internationalization is not measured only by recruitment from abroad.

Our interpretation

The research reviewed here points in one direction: the number of foreign nationals on a payroll is the starting point of measurement, not its result. Each definition in the comparison table captures something real, and each misses something important, so the most honest reporting uses at least two definitions and states the denominator, the staff categories included and the reference date. The qualitative studies from Thailand and England suggest that the most informative gaps lie in contract security, promotion and recognized workload, and these can be measured with data most universities already hold. We also read the evidence as a caution against treating a high international share as a sign of quality. Under Pustelnikovaite's and Cheng's findings, a large international workforce can coexist with limited mobility options, opaque promotion and unrecognized labour. Finally, small groups raise a privacy problem: breaking down promotion data by nationality in a small department can identify individuals, so aggregation thresholds should be set before publication.

Practical steps for universities and evaluators

  1. Publish the definition. State whether "international" means citizenship, birthplace, doctoral country, prior employment or recent residence, and keep the definition stable across years.
  2. Report at least two definitions side by side, for example citizenship and country of doctoral qualification, so that home nationals trained abroad and locally trained foreign nationals are both visible.
  3. Separate staff categories. Report core academic staff, part-time staff and visiting appointments separately, in both headcount and full-time equivalent.
  4. Cross-tabulate by contract type. Show the share of international staff on open-ended, fixed-term and hourly contracts compared with other staff.
  5. Track careers. Monitor grade distribution, promotion applications and outcomes, and exits by group, with exit interviews that ask about immigration, contract and family factors.
  6. Make contributions visible. Record teaching, supervision, student support and committee roles, and check that roles assigned because of language or cultural knowledge carry workload allocation.
  7. Assess the environment. Offer orientation for incoming staff, check language access to meetings and key documents, and include staff in climate surveys and complaint data.
  8. For evaluators: ask for definitions and denominators before comparing institutions, and treat cross-country differences in light of national employment, immigration and language contexts.

Limitations

This review draws on seven peer-reviewed sources. Three were read in full (Macfarlane and Chen, 2026; Schartner, Young and Snodin, 2023; Cheng, 2026) and four from abstracts only (Pustelnikovaite, 2021; Cañibano and colleagues, 2020; Shen, Xu and Wang, 2022; Singh, 2024). The empirical studies are mostly qualitative, based on samples of 17 to 62 participants in single countries, and cannot be generalized to national rates. Macfarlane and Chen's paper is conceptual. The Eurostat figures cited concern researchers in the higher education sector rather than all academic staff, and published coverage varies by country. National staff statistics for the UK were consulted only through the official release page, which lists nationality among its topics; detailed figures are not reported here. A peer-reviewed comparison of definition effects across national systems was identified but not used because its main subject is a ranking indicator.

Related reading on UNIRANKS

For the wider evaluation framework, see How Should Universities Measure Internationalization? and the Internationalization & Diversity research hub. For academic networking as a separate topic, see why collaboration matters in research.

Editorial disclosure

UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes an Internationalization & Diversity dimension. This article reviews independent research on measuring international faculty diversity. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.

Research References

  1. Cañibano, C., D'Este, P., Otamendi, F. J., et al. (2020). Scientific careers and the mobility of European researchers: an analysis of international mobility by career stage. Higher Education, 80(6), 1175-1193. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-020-00536-z (verified 21 November 2026)
  2. Cheng, M. (2026). Navigating microaggressions in the workplace: experiences of Chinese international academics in England. Higher Education, advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-026-01723-0 (verified 21 November 2026)
  3. Macfarlane, B., & Chen, L. H. (2026). Decolonising and re-imagining the concept of the international academic. Higher Education, 92(4), 2221-2235. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-025-01617-7 (verified 21 November 2026)
  4. Pustelnikovaite, T. (2021). Locked out, locked in and stuck: exploring migrant academics' experiences of moving to the UK. Higher Education, 82(4), 783-797. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-020-00640-0 (verified 21 November 2026)
  5. Schartner, A., Young, T. J., & Snodin, N. (2023). Intercultural adjustment of internationally mobile academics working in Thailand. Higher Education, 85(3), 483-502. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-022-00846-4 (verified 21 November 2026)
  6. Shen, W., Xu, X., & Wang, X. (2022). Reconceptualising international academic mobility in the global knowledge system: towards a new research agenda. Higher Education, 84(6), 1317-1342. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-022-00931-8 (verified 21 November 2026)
  7. Singh, J. K. N. (2024). Migrant academics' career capital experiences in Australian universities: a qualitative study. Higher Education, 88(3), 957-974. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-023-01152-3 (verified 21 November 2026)

Sources

Share this article