Independent university campus safety audit showing security inspections, fire protection, emergency alerts and access control.

Should University Campus Safety Be Independently Audited?

Share

Independent campus safety audits can strengthen the credibility of institutional safety reporting, especially when findings, corrective actions and follow-up evidence are made available. Existing research identifies important weaknesses in relying exclusively on institutional self-reporting. A 2025 peer-reviewed review of publicly documented health and safety incidents at South African universities between 2015 and 2024 found that safety audits, when conducted, were often not publicly released or supported by proof that they were acted upon, and that the sector lacked sector-wide standards and mandated national compliance monitoring. Its authors recommend that annual safety audits be made mandatory, published and externally verified. That is a recommendation from researchers, not an existing legal requirement. For anyone comparing universities, the implication is that a claim to be safe is not, on its own, evidence of safety. Verified conditions, published findings and documented follow-up are stronger evidence, although even a good audit does not by itself establish that a campus is safe.

This article reviews the South African research, sets it against the safety verification provisions that South African policy already contains, draws on United States evidence about the limits of mandated crime reporting, and outlines what a credible independent campus safety audit should cover.

What the South African Research Shows

The anchor study is "Health and Safety Challenges in South African Universities: A Qualitative Review of Campus Risks and Institutional Responses" by Maasago Mercy Sepadi (Tshwane University of Technology) and Martha Chadyiwa (Sefako Makgatho Health Sciences University), published online on 23 June 2025 in the International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health (volume 22, issue 7, article 989). It is a document-based qualitative review. The authors analyzed publicly available material, including national policy documents, academic literature, South African Police Service crime statistics, university press statements and public reports, and national media coverage of safety incidents at South African universities from 2015 to 2024. Documents were selected purposively and analyzed thematically, using public health and victimology frameworks.

The review identified reported cases of gender-based violence, student deaths, residence safety concerns and infrastructure failures during 2015 to 2024. The examples it documents include media-reported killings of students in 2023 and a suspected arson attack on a university building in the same year. Because the evidence comes from secondary sources, it cannot establish comprehensive national incident rates or trends, and media coverage of individual incidents is not a measure of how often incidents occur. The authors also describe a pattern of poor infrastructure management, weak communication between institutions and failure to implement recommendations after major incidents.

Weak verification and follow-up

For evaluation, the most important findings concern what happens after risks are identified. The review states: "Safety audits, when conducted, were often not publicly released or provided proof that they were acted upon." It adds that "the lack of sector-wide standards or mandated national compliance monitoring continues to exacerbate inconsistencies." The authors also report that, during crises such as fires, violent protests or student deaths, communication with students and staff was often delayed, inconsistent or vague, and that the few institutions with formal protocols, such as SMS alert systems and detailed incident reporting pathways, remained outliers.

Among their policy proposals, the authors argue that universities should be legally required to conduct and publish annual safety audits covering physical infrastructure, security protocols and emergency preparedness, and that these audits should be externally verified. They also propose that the Department of Higher Education and Training introduce a conditional grant system linking public funding to minimum campus safety benchmarks. These are the authors' recommendations; neither is currently established by a South African legal instrument identified in this review.

Residences and infrastructure

The review documents substandard conditions in some university residences, including overcrowding, poor ventilation, inadequate sanitation and inadequate maintenance. It identifies inadequate funding as a constraint on investment in safety infrastructure, security personnel and emergency response systems.

Data that cannot isolate universities

The authors draw on South African Police Service crime statistics for educational institutions, but note that these figures group universities together with schools, colleges and day-care facilities. Separating university-specific data from these broader statistics is one of the limitations they acknowledge.

Underreporting of sexual violence

A second study explains why reported numbers cannot stand in for actual risk. Makhaye, Mkhize and Sibanyoni (2023), writing in SN Social Sciences, interviewed 60 participants, selected by purposive sampling, at three universities in the Durban area of KwaZulu-Natal: 30 students, 15 risk management staff and 15 student support staff. Within that sample, the study confirmed that female students are reluctant to report sexual victimization to the authorities, and participants linked underreporting to factors such as distrust of the justice system and the relationship between victim and perpetrator. Participants described poor lighting, a lack of security patrols, weak access control at gates and too few security personnel at residences, and the authors recommend more regular patrols, CCTV coverage, better lighting and security guards stationed at residences. The study does not estimate a reporting rate, and the authors note that the small sample means the findings may not be generalized beyond the three institutions.

South African Policy Already Provides for Safety Checks

The gap identified in the research is not an absence of policy. Two national policy documents from the Department of Higher Education and Training already provide for forms of safety verification. It helps to keep three different things apart: the annual compliance certificates required for student housing by the 2015 housing policy; the campus and residence safety audits that the 2020 gender-based violence framework expects institutions to undertake; and the annual, published, externally verified campus-wide audits that Sepadi and Chadyiwa recommend. Only the first two appear in national policy, and neither takes the form the researchers propose.

Safety verification duties in two South African higher education policies
Policy What it requires What it leaves open
Policy on the Minimum Norms and Standards for Student Housing at Public Universities (Government Gazette No. 39238, September 2015) Published under section 3 of the Higher Education Act. Annual certificates of compliance from the relevant authority for fire safety, prevention and detection; electricity and gas installations; and security staff, mechanisms and procedures. Secure rooms and buildings; monthly internal hygiene inspections in addition to annual municipal or equivalent hygiene audits; a displayed certificate of compliance with occupational health and safety regulations and an evacuation diagram; liaison with local enforcement agencies dealing with student safety. The level of compliance is to be included in each university's annual report. The Department may inspect new or refurbished residence buildings and may undertake annual site visits to inspect residences. The policy also applies to university-accredited private housing, which the feeder university accredits. Establishes detailed housing requirements, but does not itself create a unified public reporting framework for independently verified campus-wide safety audits.
Policy Framework to Address Gender-Based Violence in the Post-School Education and Training System (July 2020) Among the prevention actions it sets out, institutions are to undertake safety audits of campuses and residences, identify places where students and staff feel unsafe or where abuse could easily occur, and address deficiencies, for example through adequate lighting at night, access to help lines and security accompaniment. Institutions are also to report quarterly and annually to the Department on implementation, and all responses to gender-based violence must maintain the confidentiality and privacy of the complainant. Who conducts the audits, what standard they follow, whether findings are published and how follow-up is verified

The gender-based violence framework is explicit that "safety audits must also identify those parts of campus where students and staff feel unsafe, or where abuse could easily occur." In other words, safety audits are already expected under national policy, although the framework does not specify who carries them out or whether results are published. What the 2025 review found missing is consistent publication, independent verification and evidence of follow-up. The Department also published a draft revised housing policy, covering public institutions of higher learning, for public comment in October 2021; a December 2021 notice extended the comment period to 31 March 2022. As of 21 November 2026, no final revised policy had been found in the official sources checked for this article. In an address of 28 August 2026, the Minister of Higher Education and Training described the 2015 university policy as the clearly published baseline and said the revised minimum norms and standards for student housing across the post-school system were moving through the required legal and gazetting processes. The Department's revised strategic plan for 2025 to 2030 continues to list the 2020 gender-based violence framework among the legislative and policy mandates the Department is responsible for implementing.

Why Internal Safety Reporting Is Not Enough

Universities have understandable reasons to present their campuses as safe, because incidents affect reputation and recruitment. This does not imply bad faith, but it does mean that self-reported safety information has structural limits:

  • Selective disclosure. If audits are commissioned internally and findings are not published, outsiders cannot know what was found or whether it was fixed.
  • Inconsistent definitions. Without a sector-wide standard, two universities may define a "safety incident" or a "secure residence" differently, which makes comparison unreliable.
  • Underreporting. As the Durban study illustrates, students may be reluctant to report sexual victimization, so some incidents never reach official records. Low reported numbers can reflect weak reporting systems rather than safe campuses.
  • Off-campus blind spots. South African policy extends housing norms to accredited private accommodation, and the gender-based violence framework points to safety challenges both on and off campus. Audits limited to university-owned buildings miss much of the student environment.

Lessons From Mandated Disclosure in the United States

The United States shows both the value and the limits of mandated reporting. Under the federal regulation implementing the Clery Act, 34 CFR 668.46, covered institutions must prepare an annual security report with statistics for the three most recent calendar years on specified crimes that occur within their defined Clery geography (campus, noncampus buildings and property, and adjacent public property) and are reported to local police or campus security authorities. They must also issue timely warnings that withhold the names and other identifying information of victims, follow procedures to immediately notify the campus community of significant emergencies, and test their emergency response and evacuation procedures at least once a year. These rules create comparable public data and a legal duty to report, applied separately to each campus.

Mandated reporting alone, however, does not guarantee accuracy. Rochford, Peek-Asa, Zahnd and Kaskie (2025), in the Journal of American College Health (volume 73, issue 5), compared public Clery Act figures with data from institutional Title IX coordinator offices, which are not required to be public, at 40 institutions within the Association of American Universities (AAU) from 2014 to 2020. According to the abstract, Clery Act data offer a considerable undercount relative to Title IX office data, and the authors conclude that Clery data are not appropriate for evaluating campus sexual misconduct. Because the two systems use different legal definitions and reporting channels, the datasets do not describe identical populations of incidents; the finding concerns what each system captures, not a precise measure of missing cases.

Independent audits can expose such gaps. California law requires the California State Auditor to audit at least six institutions that receive federal student aid every three years. In its May 2021 report, the State Auditor found shortcomings at all six institutions it reviewed: all four that reported criminal offenses had inaccurate or incomplete statistics, and only one of the six adhered to all requirements to disclose specific security policies. The auditor also found that written procedures alone were not sufficient to ensure compliance. A later report, published in July 2024 on six different institutions, found that five reported inaccurate crime statistics, four had omissions in their daily crime logs and none had fully complied with the required security policy disclosures. Both audits tested samples of records at a small number of selected institutions, and the auditor cautions that such results should not be projected to all institutions.

The United States example is offered only as a comparison. Legal systems, policing and campus contexts differ substantially, and no country's model can simply be transplanted. The common lesson is that published statistics are more credible when an external body periodically checks them.

What an Independent Campus Safety Audit Should Measure

An audit useful for evaluation should assess conditions and capacity, not only policies. Drawing on the risks documented in the South African studies and the requirements in national policy, a rigorous framework would cover the areas below. The table is an editorial synthesis. It is not a national standard, it is not drawn from any single policy and it is not a UNIRANKS scoring framework; it sets no numerical benchmarks.

Suggested scope of an independent campus safety audit
Audit area What to verify Example evidence
Physical environment Lighting, sightlines, access control, emergency call points and CCTV coverage on campus and on main student routes Site inspection, night-time walk audits, maps of coverage gaps
Residences Compliance with housing norms: occupancy, ventilation, fire safety, locks and security staffing Inspection reports and compliance certificates for each residence, including accredited private housing
Security capacity Security staffing per site, training and response times Staffing rosters, response-time logs
Gender-based violence response Reporting channels, survivor support, case handling times and staff training Policy documents, anonymized case data, support unit staffing
Emergency communication Ability to warn students quickly about threats Alert system tests, time from incident to notification
Incident data Consistent recording of incidents and publication of aggregate figures Annual statistics using defined categories, with notes on reporting channels
Follow-up and remediation Whether previous findings were fixed, and whether fixes were checked Remediation plan with dates, budgets and status; evidence from a follow-up visit

Independence matters as much as scope. An audit is more credible when a qualified external party with no stake in the outcome carries it out against a published standard, a summary of findings is made public and the audit is repeated on a regular cycle so progress can be tracked. Several design questions shape how much an audit can show:

  • Independence and competence. The auditor should be free of reporting lines to the units being audited and should have relevant expertise, for example in security, fire and building safety, occupational health and gender-based violence response.
  • Scope and sampling. The audit report should state which sites, residences, time periods and records were examined and how samples were chosen, so readers know what the findings do and do not cover.
  • Campus and off-campus responsibilities. The report should distinguish university-owned facilities from accredited or leased private accommodation and public routes, where the university's control is more limited.
  • Confidentiality. Published summaries should not identify survivors, witnesses, complainants or students involved in identifiable incidents, should not disclose confidential support records and should not describe security vulnerabilities in operational detail. In South Africa, the Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013 requires responsible parties to secure the personal information they hold and restricts the processing of special personal information, including information about a person's health or sex life and alleged criminal behavior.
  • Evidence retention. The auditor and the institution should keep the underlying evidence securely, so that findings can be checked later without being published in full.
  • Remediation tracking and follow-up verification. Each finding should have an owner, a deadline and a status, and a later visit should confirm that fixes were made.
  • Measures versus outcomes. An audit mainly verifies conditions, procedures and compliance. Physical measures such as lighting or CCTV are not the same as demonstrated reductions in harm, and student perceptions of safety are a separate question from recorded incidents.

Transparency, in this sense, means publishing enough for outsiders to judge what was found and what was fixed. It does not mean unrestricted disclosure.

Our Interpretation

Safety is a precondition for learning. A student who avoids the library after dark, cannot sleep securely in a residence or fears the walk to class cannot benefit fully from what a university provides. Campus safety and housing are among the areas named in the official description of the Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension of the UNIRANKS methodology, which covers "the physical, social and support environment available to students throughout their university experience."

Measuring safety responsibly is difficult. The three studies reviewed here point in the same direction: raw incident counts reflect reporting as much as risk, and self-declared safety statements cannot be checked. In our reading, the most defensible evidence of safety is verifiable: published independent audits, documented remediation, credible reporting systems and adequate response capacity. A university that publishes difficult findings and fixes them shows stronger safety management than one that publishes nothing. None of the studies tested whether independent audits by themselves reduce crime, so this is an argument about evidence quality, not a proven effect on outcomes. It helps to separate several kinds of evidence: process evidence (whether policies and procedures exist and are followed), compliance (whether specific requirements are met), remediation (whether identified problems are fixed), student perceptions of safety and actual incidence or outcomes. An independent audit mainly strengthens confidence in the first three. It can make reported conditions more credible, but it does not establish that a campus is safe. Questions about how students perceive safety belong to the separate Student Experience & Satisfaction dimension.

The recommendations in this article are drawn from research and editorial analysis. They are not UNIRANKS requirements, they do not describe any weights, thresholds or scores, and commissioning or paying for an audit has no bearing on how a university appears in UNIRANKS rankings.

Practical Steps for University Stakeholders

For university leaders

  • Commission a qualified independent safety audit and publish a privacy-protective summary of findings and corrective actions, withholding personally identifiable information and sensitive operational security details.
  • Attach a funded, dated remediation plan to each audit and report progress every year.
  • Make it easier, not harder, for students to report incidents, including confidentially.

For institutional research and safety teams

  • Record incidents using consistent categories and publish annual aggregate statistics with context on reporting channels, without details that could identify individuals.
  • Track response times and survivor support capacity, not only incident numbers.
  • Include accredited off-campus accommodation in inspection programs.

For policymakers and regulators

  • Consider defining a sector-wide audit standard and periodic external verification, as the 2025 review recommends, building on the compliance certificates and safety audits already provided for in national policy.
  • Consider whether linking part of public funding to minimum campus safety benchmarks would help, a conditional-grant approach the review's authors propose.
  • Collect national crime data that separate universities from schools and other educational settings.

For students and families

  • Ask whether the university has had an independent safety audit and whether the findings are public.
  • Ask about residence security, night-time transport and how incidents can be reported confidentially.

Limitations

This article draws on three research studies: two read in full (Sepadi and Chadyiwa, 2025; Makhaye, Mkhize and Sibanyoni, 2023) and one from its abstract only (Rochford and colleagues, 2025). The South African review relies entirely on secondary data, such as media reports, press releases and public documents; its authors acknowledge possible underreporting, limited access to internal university reports and findings that cannot be generalized to all South African institutions. The Durban study is qualitative, with a small sample from one province. The United States evidence comes from a different legal and policing context, and the California audits examined samples of records at a small number of selected institutions. None of the studies measured the effect of independent audits on safety outcomes. The description of South African policy reflects the official documents checked on 21 November 2026; a revised student housing policy was still in preparation at that date.

Conclusion

South Africa has national policies on student housing and gender-based violence that already call for compliance certificates and campus safety audits. Yet a decade of documented incidents suggests that policy has not been matched by consistent, transparent verification. The clearest recommendation from the research is also the simplest: audit campus safety every year, have the audit verified externally, publish a privacy-protective summary of the findings and show what has been fixed. That remains the researchers' proposal rather than a legal requirement. Universities that open their safety conditions to external scrutiny provide stronger evidence for their safety claims, although an audit alone cannot show that a campus is safe.

Related reading on UNIRANKS

For more research in this area, see the Student Wellbeing & Facilities hub, What Should Universities Measure When Evaluating Student Wellbeing & Facilities? and How Do Campus Facilities Influence Student Success? For the residence questions raised here, see Student Accommodation Data: Definitions & University Comparisons; for another example of checking whether a campus policy is applied in practice, see Smoke-Free Campus Policies: What Evaluators Should Check.

Editorial disclosure

UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes a Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension. This article reviews independent research on campus safety audits. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.

Research References

  1. Sepadi, M. M., & Chadyiwa, M. (2025). Health and Safety Challenges in South African Universities: A Qualitative Review of Campus Risks and Institutional Responses. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 22(7), 989. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph22070989 (verified 21 November 2026)
  2. Makhaye, M. S., Mkhize, S. M., & Sibanyoni, E. K. (2023). Female students as victims of sexual abuse at institutions of higher learning: insights from Kwazulu-natal, South Africa. SN Social Sciences, 3(2), 40. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43545-023-00611-z (verified 21 November 2026)
  3. Rochford, H., Peek-Asa, C., Zahnd, W., & Kaskie, B. (2025). The Clery Act’s transparency purpose & campus sexual misconduct: A longitudinal analysis. Journal of American College Health, 73(5), 2116-2128. https://doi.org/10.1080/07448481.2025.2461606 (verified 21 November 2026)

Sources

Share this article