Campus sustainability can be measured, but it is rarely measured in a way that allows fair comparison between universities. A 2026 systematic literature review of 90 publications on campus operations notes, citing earlier work, that "the absence of standardised, globally adopted performance indicators remains a collective barrier," and finds that explicit links between campus practices and Sustainable Development Goal targets are rare. Published energy, water and waste figures can be accurate for one institution yet incompatible with another's, because they use different denominators, baselines, boundaries and reporting years. For evaluators, the useful question is not whether a university reports sustainability data, but whether its numbers are defined well enough to be checked and compared.
This matters for students because the estates decisions that reduce emissions also shape whether drinking water is easy to find, whether students can walk or cycle to campus safely and how buildings cope with heat.
What does the research say about campus sustainability measurement?
A recent synthesis is a systematic literature review, which its authors describe as following the PRISMA guidelines, by Aniefon Essien, Eghosa Ekhaese and Daniel Babalola of the Department of Architecture, Covenant University, Nigeria, published in Frontiers in Sustainable Cities on 24 February 2026. The authors searched Scopus, Web of Science, ScienceDirect and Emerald Insight for English-language, peer-reviewed work published between 2015 and 2025 and included 90 publications on smart sustainable campus operations. They organize campus operations into five domains: energy management, water management, waste management, sustainable mobility, and setting and infrastructure.
The review's main conclusions are qualitative:
- Energy is the most mature domain. The authors describe energy management as "the most technologically advanced," benefiting from long-standing investment in smart grids and renewable energy.
- Water and waste are in between. The review describes them as showing "moderate innovation," with more progress where water stress or regulation applies pressure.
- Mobility lags. Sustainable mobility is described as comparatively underdeveloped and often limited to pilot initiatives.
- Measurable commitments are uncommon. The authors write that "only a minority of reviewed institutions link their campus strategies to these commitments in measurable ways" and that "explicit mapping between SSC practices and SDG targets remains rare."
- Constraints differ by context. Institutions in developing countries face financial limits, deficient or outdated technical infrastructure, a lack of long-term sustainability planning and a digital divide, but the review also describes, citing Silva-da-Nóbrega and colleagues (2022), low-cost, community-based solutions such as solar-powered drinking water purification and decentralized composting units.
Several of these characterizations rest on citations to earlier studies rather than on new measurement: the energy statement cites Zhou and Zheng (2024), the water and waste statement cites Wang and colleagues (2023), and the developing-country constraints cite Ribeiro and colleagues (2020) and Serafini and colleagues (2022). They are best read as the review's summary of that literature.
The review also observes that building standards such as LEED and BREEAM are design-based certifications focused on single buildings rather than performance instruments for multi-building campuses, and, citing Makhoul (2022), that campus indicator systems, STARS among them, often suffer from inconsistency in reporting parameters and a lack of longitudinal data. The sentence on standardized indicators quoted above appears in this discussion of benchmarking limitations, where the authors cite earlier work by Cunha and colleagues.
How reliable is this evidence?
The review should be read for its direction rather than its precision. It reports no percentages for how many institutions use standardized metrics, so its finding is a qualitative judgment. Its screening account is also hard to follow: the 2015 to 2025 timeframe is applied twice, duplicate removals are not counted, 15 non-English articles are excluded at a late stage although an English-only filter was applied at the first step, and an appraisal checklist is mentioned without results. The authors acknowledge that limiting the search to English-language publications and academic databases may have excluded relevant studies and gray literature.
Other reviews point the same way. A 2025 review in Frontiers in Education by Zohar Barnett-Itzhaki of Ruppin Academic Center, Israel, and colleagues, drawing on over 130 studies, reports and initiatives, states, citing Ávila and colleagues (2017), that "the lack of clear assessment and reporting methodologies makes it difficult to objectively evaluate and compare the progress of sustainability integration across HEIs." Citing earlier studies, it also reports that green campus assessment tools often overlook health. In 2017, Naif Alghamdi, Alexandra den Heijer and Hans de Jonge analyzed 12 university sustainability assessment tools in the International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education and found, according to the abstract, that the tools "share similar traits in terms of criteria, sub-criteria and indicators." Taken together, these sources suggest that the problem is not a lack of tools but a lack of agreement on how the same quantity should be counted.
The concern is not new. The United Nations Environment Programme's Greening Universities Toolkit V2.0 (2014) observed that sometimes "failure to develop appropriate performance measures limits direct feedback" on the benefits of sustainability actions. That a similar concern recurs in 2026 suggests that common measurement has developed slowly.
How does a reporting framework define campus sustainability metrics?
The Sustainability Tracking, Assessment & Rating System (STARS), operated by the Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education (AASHE), is a detailed, publicly documented framework for campus reporting, which its technical manual describes as "a voluntary, self-reporting framework." Version 3.0 was launched on 18 June 2024 after almost five years of development, with what AASHE calls "streamlined, performance-based credits," and the technical manual was updated to version 3.0.1 in July 2025 with minor corrections and clarifications. Its definitions show what consistent measurement requires in practice.
| Category | Points | Share of 250 maximum points | Examples of credits (maximum points) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Academics | 68 | 27.2% | Sustainability course offerings (14), undergraduate programs (15, or 11 where one indicator does not apply), sustainability research (10) |
| Engagement | 50 | 20.0% | Co-curricular activities (9), community partnerships (9) |
| Operations | 86 | 34.4% | Greenhouse gas emissions (16), energy use (10), water use (7 or 6), dining service procurement (8), commute modal split (6) |
| Planning & Administration | 46 | 18.4% | Commitments and planning (6), sustainable investment program (4), affordability and access (3), health, safety and wellbeing (3) |
Sources: AASHE, STARS 3.0 Point Allocation (January 2024), checked against the STARS Technical Manual v3.0.1 (July 2025). Category totals are summed from the published impact-area maximums, and the shares are exact proportions of 250. The 250 points are a maximum: some credits offer fewer points depending on an institution's context (water use offers 7 or 6, investment holdings 6 or 3), credits that do not apply to an institution do not count against its score, and up to 10 Innovation & Leadership bonus points can be added. The shares are therefore not the effective weights for any individual institution. They are STARS values, not UNIRANKS weights.
Denominators and benchmarks
The operations credits are where definitions become concrete. Energy must be reported in megawatt-hours. Two of the energy credit's four indicators (3 of its 10 points each) score consumption per gross square meter and per full-time equivalent (FTE) student and employee against a benchmark for the institution's peer group (associate's, baccalaureate, master's or doctoral); the other two score the share of energy and electricity from renewable sources. Transportation fuels are excluded from the energy total. STARS defines FTE as a unit that makes people who work or study different hours comparable, calculated according to relevant national, regional or international standards, and allows any standard definition of gross floor area provided it is used consistently, with parking structures excluded.
The water credit has four indicators. Indicator 3.1 (potable water use per FTE person) is worth 2 points: doctoral universities and research institutions earn the full 2 points at or below a benchmark of 4,135 liters per FTE person per year, with partial points scaled between that benchmark and a maximum threshold of 62,530 liters. Indicator 3.2 (potable water use per gross square meter, 2 points) uses a separate benchmark of 362 liters per square meter and a maximum threshold of 2,011 liters for the same peer group, and the remaining 2 or 3 points come from water recovery and return. The benchmark therefore governs only one part of the credit, not the whole water score. These values are the same in the v3.0 and v3.0.1 technical manuals. Population and floor-area figures must come from the same period as the water data.
Each rule removes a source of incomparability: peer groups, defined by the degrees an institution awards, separate doctoral and research institutions from associate's, baccalaureate and master's institutions, and matching periods stop a year of low enrollment from distorting intensity.
What the framework still leaves open
- Climate. AASHE notes that previous versions of STARS normalized energy by weather (degree days); version 3.0 normalizes energy by population, building space and institution type instead. Institutions report a climate zone in the report preface, but a cooling-dependent campus in a hot climate is benchmarked against the same peer-group threshold as a temperate one. Water scoring gives more weight to one indicator (water recovered or returned) for campuses in areas of high or extremely high physical water quantity risk, as determined by the World Resources Institute Aqueduct Water Risk Atlas (7 rather than 6 points in total), but does not change the benchmarks.
- Reporting period. Energy and water data are the most recent annual data from within the previous three years (a single year or an average over the period), and each report and rating is valid for three years from publication. Two published reports may therefore describe different years.
- Verification. Four levels need to be kept apart. First, STARS data are self-reported by each institution. Second, when an institution submits a scored report for a rating, AASHE staff review it "for accuracy and adherence to credit criteria," and the issues they identify must be resolved before publication; this is an administrative and technical review against the credit criteria, not an independent audit of the underlying data. Third, independent assurance, such as review by a peer institution or a contracted assurance provider, is strongly recommended but not required; each report must state whether independent audits or external assurance processes were used. Fourth, unscored Reporter submissions receive no AASHE staff review.
- Boundary. Each institution is expected to include its entire main campus, but it may exclude features, schools or buildings provided a majority of campus space and demographics are included and the rationale is documented.
- Participation. Voluntary participants are not a random sample of universities.
What do published university data show about comparability?
Two institutional datasets show how far apart sensible reporting choices can be. Both are useful for tracking each university's own progress; neither can be compared directly with the other or with a framework benchmark.
Bocconi University, Italy. Bocconi publishes key environmental performance indicators for 2023 and 2024. Water consumption is reported per user, defined as faculty, staff and students: 11.4 cubic meters per user in 2024 (205,877 cubic meters across 18,006 users), compared with 11.5 in 2023. Energy is reported as 0.28 gigajoules per square meter of built space (331,673 square meters), and the energy total includes diesel and gasoline as well as electricity, gas and district heating. The university also reports student-facing indicators, including drinking water dispensed (33.4 liters per user, excluding residences) and bicycle racks per 1,000 users (33 in 2024, up from 28). The page does not mention external verification.
The page also shows two slightly different 2024 waste totals: 219,967 kilograms of municipal waste in the waste-per-capita table, and 219,817 kilograms of total waste as the denominator in the recycling table. The 2023 totals in the two tables match (207,596 kilograms). Bocconi's published environmental indicators thus use slightly different 2024 waste totals in its waste-per-capita and recycling calculations. The difference illustrates why evaluators should inspect source definitions and reconciliation notes before combining institutional metrics.
The University of Hong Kong. The HKU Estates Office Campus Sustainability Report 2024 covers the 12-month period from September 2023 to August 2024 and expresses carbon, electricity, water and waste per capita. Electricity use fell from 3,913 to 3,515 kilowatt-hours per person per year, 10.2% below the 2017/18 baseline. Water, however, is reported as a change rather than a level: per capita use is 30.7% below the 2017/18 baseline (total consumption is 9.4% below it), and no absolute water volume appears in the report's text, tables or the text of its charts, where water is shown as an index (2017/18 = 100). The report's carbon and waste charts plot the "Total Number of Student and Staff" alongside the per capita series, but the report does not tabulate these population figures or state whether they are headcounts or FTE, and it does not state which campuses or facilities the per capita metrics cover. No external assurance or verification statement appears in the report; the audits it mentions are operational (regular waste audits and a planned campus energy audit).
| Reporting choice | Bocconi University (2024) | University of Hong Kong (2023/24) | STARS 3.0 rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water denominator | Per user (faculty, staff, students) | Per capita (students and staff, per chart legends; headcount or FTE not stated) | Per FTE student and employee, and per square meter |
| Water figure published | Absolute volume and level (205,877 m³; 11.4 m³ per user) | Change against 2017/18 baseline (minus 30.7% per capita) | Absolute volume reported (m³); intensities scored against peer benchmarks |
| Energy denominator | Per square meter of built space (total includes diesel and gasoline) | Electricity per person | Per square meter and per FTE (transportation fuels excluded) |
| Reporting period | Annual (labeled 2024; period not defined on the page) | Academic year (September to August) | Recent annual data within previous three years |
| External assurance stated | None mentioned on the page | None found in the report | AASHE staff review for rated reports only; independent assurance optional and disclosed |
A headcount denominator and an FTE denominator can differ substantially where many students study part-time, so a per-user figure cannot be placed against a per-FTE benchmark without conversion, and a percentage change cannot be compared with another university's absolute level at all. Both datasets are designed to answer "are we improving?" rather than "how do we compare?"
Which sustainability measures relate most directly to students?
The reviews and frameworks largely measure institutional performance. For students, the relevant question is which parts of sustainable operations change what they can use.
- Drinking water access. Refill points and dispensed volumes, such as Bocconi's dispenser indicator, are both a waste measure and a provision measure: students can only avoid bottled water where free, safe water is available.
- Active and public transport. Cycle parking, safe routes and transit access shape how students reach campus. STARS 3.0 allocates 6 points to its commute modal split credit, whose single indicator is the percentage of students and employees using more sustainable commuting options.
- Dining supply. STARS dining service procurement and food recovery credits concern what is served on campus and what happens to surplus food.
- Building performance. As a hypothetical tradeoff, an efficiency gain achieved by cutting ventilation or cooling would improve an energy metric while worsening study conditions.
That last point matters. Sustainability performance and student conditions can reinforce one another, but improvements in operational efficiency do not automatically establish better learning or living conditions. The Essien review links indoor environmental quality to occupant comfort, health and productivity (SDG 3) and sustainable learning environments to SDG 4. An evaluator who relies only on energy intensity will not see whether lecture halls, libraries and residences remain healthy places to learn.
Our interpretation: what can evaluators responsibly verify?
Given the state of the evidence, in our view the most defensible approach is to evaluate the quality of sustainability reporting and selected student-facing provision rather than to compare universities on raw intensity figures. The checklist below is our synthesis of the evidence above, not an established standard and not a description of UNIRANKS indicators.
| What to check | Example evidence | Why it matters | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Absolute levels, not only percentage change | Annual energy (MWh), water (m³), waste (tonnes) | Enables intensity calculations when compatible denominator data, operational boundaries and reporting periods are available | Levels alone ignore size and type |
| Declared denominators | FTE or headcount; floor-area definition | Shows whether intensities can be converted or compared | Neither example university publishes both |
| Declared boundary and period | Campuses included or excluded; fiscal, calendar or academic year | Prevents comparing different scopes or years | Boundaries still differ |
| Multi-year trend | At least three comparable years | A trend within one institution is more reliable than levels between institutions | Baselines can be reset |
| Assurance | Independent third-party assurance statement, reported separately from any framework staff review | Distinguishes independently checked data from self-reported data that has had only an administrative or technical review against framework criteria | Framework review checks adherence to credit criteria, not the underlying records; assurance scope varies |
| Student-facing provision | Water refill points, cycle parking per 1,000 users, safe active-travel routes | Connects sustainability to what students can use | Counts do not show quality or location |
| Context | Climate, water stress, laboratory intensity | Avoids penalizing institutions for climate or research mix | STARS 3.0 does not adjust energy benchmarks for climate |
This proposed approach prioritizes transparent, well-defined and appropriately assured reporting while recognizing contextual differences such as climate, water stress and institutional research intensity. Meeting every item on the checklist shows that a university's data can be checked; it does not by itself establish that two institutions' environmental performance is equivalent.
How does this relate to the Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension?
The UNIRANKS methodology describes Student Wellbeing & Facilities as evaluating "the physical, social and support environment available to students throughout their university experience," and lists sustainability among the areas the dimension examines, alongside learning facilities, laboratories, libraries, housing, dining, student services, accessibility, campus safety, healthcare and the broader learning environment. The research reviewed here supports the importance of sustainable campus operations, but not the treatment of any single intensity figure as a comparable measure of quality across countries. The checklist above is an editorial proposal, not part of the UNIRANKS methodology, and the STARS point values cited in this article are not UNIRANKS weights.
Practical steps for universities and evaluators
- Estates, institutional research and quality assurance teams: publish absolute consumption figures alongside intensities; state the denominator (ideally both FTE and headcount), floor-area definition, boundary and period every time; seek independent assurance of the main operational figures; and publish the reason and restated history whenever a baseline is revised.
- Evaluators: treat intensity figures from different institutions as non-comparable unless their definitions match, prefer evidence of reporting quality and student-facing provision over raw efficiency comparisons, and take account of climate and research intensity.
- Policymakers: in our view, shared national definitions of campus floor area, FTE and reporting periods would do more for comparability than new indicators. The low-cost solutions described by Essien and colleagues suggest that frameworks should also recognize frugal provision, not only metered, capital-intensive systems.
- Students and families: large percentage reductions in a sustainability report are not, by themselves, evidence that a campus is a better place to study. Look for free drinking water, safe walking and cycling routes, public transport access and buildings that stay comfortable.
Limitations
This article draws on three peer-reviewed sources. Two open-access reviews (Essien and colleagues, 2026; Barnett-Itzhaki and colleagues, 2025) were read in full text for the passages cited; the 2017 Alghamdi study was read from its abstract only, so no details beyond the abstract are reported. Framework rules come from AASHE's STARS 3.0 documents, including the v3.0.1 technical manual (July 2025), and the university examples from each institution's own published data, for which neither source states external assurance. No STARS score was calculated for any university. Both reviews synthesize earlier studies, and several statements reported here are attributed by their authors to that earlier work.
Related reading on UNIRANKS
For the wider evaluation context, see What Should Universities Measure When Evaluating Student Wellbeing & Facilities? and How Do Campus Facilities Influence Student Success?, or browse more research in the Student Wellbeing & Facilities category.
Editorial disclosure
UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes a Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension. This article reviews independent research on campus sustainability metrics. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.
Research References
- Essien, A., Ekhaese, E., & Babalola, D. (2026). Sustainable development strategies for smart sustainable campus operations: global trends, challenges and opportunities. Frontiers in Sustainable Cities, 8, 1747438. https://doi.org/10.3389/frsc.2026.1747438 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Barnett-Itzhaki, Z., Tifferet, S., Etstein, Y., et al. (2025). A holistic approach to sustainability in higher education institutes: social, economic, educational, and mobility perspectives. Frontiers in Education, 10, 1588223. https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2025.1588223 (verified 21 November 2026)
- Alghamdi, N., den Heijer, A., & de Jonge, H. (2017). Assessment tools' indicators for sustainability in universities: an analytical overview. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 18(1), 84-115. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJSHE-04-2015-0071 (verified 21 November 2026)
Sources
- Greening Universities Toolkit V2.0: Transforming Universities into Green and Sustainable Campuses: A Toolkit for Implementers (advance copy, 2014). United Nations Environment Programme. https://wedocs.unep.org/20.500.11822/11964 (accessed 21 November 2026)
- STARS 3.0. Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/resources-support/stars-3-0/ (accessed 21 November 2026)
- STARS 3.0 Point Allocation (January 2024). Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/STARS-3.0-Point-Allocation.pdf (accessed 21 November 2026)
- STARS Technical Manual, Version 3.0.1 (July 2025). Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/STARS-Technical-Manual-Version-3.0.1.pdf (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Energy Use (STARS 3.0 Help Center). Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/resources-support/help-center/v3-operations/energy-use/ (accessed 21 November 2026)
- OP 3: Water Use, STARS Technical Manual v3.0.1. Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/OP-03_-Water-Use-v3.0.pdf (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Institutional Characteristics (STARS 3.0 Help Center). Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/resources-support/help-center/v3-report-preface/institutional-characteristics/ (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Participate in STARS. Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/participate/ (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Data Quality & Reporting Assurance. Association for the Advancement of Sustainability in Higher Education. https://stars.aashe.org/reports-data/quality-assurance/ (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Key Environmental Performance Indicators. Bocconi University. https://www.unibocconi.it/en/about-us/sustainability/environmental-policy-and-related-management-system/key-environmental-performance-indicators (accessed 21 November 2026)
- Campus Sustainability Report 2024. Estates Office, The University of Hong Kong. https://www.estates.hku.hk/download_file/view/4509/1407 (accessed 21 November 2026)
