University library indoor environment evaluation showing lighting, noise, temperature, humidity, and air quality.

Measuring Noise, Light, Heat and Air in University Libraries

Share

University libraries can be assessed on measured indoor conditions (noise, lighting, temperature, humidity and air quality), not only on seats, holdings and opening hours, and recent field studies suggest that such measurement reveals problems that capacity figures hide. In one week of sensor measurements in a Guangzhou university library, air temperature reached 37.5 °C, the maximum recorded noise level reached 85 dB, and the authors concluded that all three measured study modules exceeded the summer temperature range in China's library design code. Capacity figures do not capture conditions like these, because they count what a library contains rather than what it is like to study in.

This article reviews what instrument-based studies of library study spaces show, where the evidence is weak, and what a defensible approach to measuring library conditions could look like.

Why Does the Physical Environment of a Library Matter?

A library is one of the few facilities that nearly every student uses. The official description of the Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension in the UNIRANKS methodology names libraries, learning facilities and "the broader learning environment" among the areas the dimension examines. The question of indoor conditions discussed here is this article's analysis of what library quality can involve, not a description of a UNIRANKS indicator, and the measurement approaches proposed below are not part of any UNIRANKS scoring formula.

Library provision is normally described in quantitative terms: number of seats, floor area, volumes, databases and hours. These figures describe capacity, not conditions. A reading hall with many seats that is too hot to use on summer afternoons, or too noisy for quiet study, provides less than its seat count suggests.

Indoor environmental quality (IEQ) is the building-science term for the combined effect of thermal comfort, air quality, lighting and acoustics. The European standard EN 16798-1:2019, according to its official catalogue entry, "specifies requirements for indoor environmental parameters for thermal environment, indoor air quality, lighting and acoustics," and it sets out different categories of criteria. It is a design and energy-calculation standard that replaced EN 15251:2007, and its own introduction notes that national regulations can override its use for certain applications. Whatever standard is chosen, the point is that these parameters can be defined and measured rather than treated as matters of taste.

What Do Field Measurements of University Libraries Show?

The instrument-based studies selected for this review examine a limited number of university libraries and differ in their measurement methods, settings and outcomes. The four below differ in method and setting, and the differences are instructive.

Guangzhou: a week of dense measurements in one library

Wang and colleagues, writing in Scientific Reports (published 11 April 2026), first surveyed ten university libraries in Guangdong Province, China, to select a case, and then measured one: the Wushan Library of South China University of Technology in Guangzhou. Between 11 and 18 September 2023, from 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m., they collected 3,290 physical measurements, more than 300,000 indoor positioning records and 532 valid questionnaires. Three types of informal learning space were examined: personal and public, open and communicable, and cooperative and intimate. Each module was divided into zones, and the values below refer to individual zones unless stated otherwise; where a zone had several measuring points, the authors used their average.

  • Light: daylight produced large swings. Maximum illuminance reached nearly 1,900 lux in one zone of the personal and public module and exceeded 1,800 lux in one zone of the open module, while one zone in each of these modules could fall below 100 lux when the lights were off. The authors take that 100 lux minimum from the Chinese library hygiene standard GB 9669-1996, which China's national standards database now lists as abolished. The problem was therefore both glare and shortfall, depending on the seat and the hour.
  • Noise: the authors found noise in all areas to be unstable (fluctuating by more than 3 dB(A)) and measured it in 20-minute periods. In the personal and public module, the zone averages were 47.2, 46.8 and 39.6 dB. The authors compare these with a 45 dB quiet-area limit that they attribute to the Chinese library design code JGJ 38-2015, and conclude that only the quietest zone basically met it; instantaneous peaks in this module reached 80 dB. In the open module they report maximum levels of 67 to 85 dB in four zones and state that all four basically exceeded the 50 dB limit. That comparison sets the loudest recorded moments against a limit for the general sound level of a room, so it shows that loud events were frequent, not that typical conditions were 17 to 35 dB above the limit. The paper does not report equivalent continuous levels (LAeq) over a stated period. In the text of JGJ 38-2015 consulted for this article, the code's allowable A-weighted noise levels for building design are 40 dB in quiet zones (which include ordinary reading rooms), 45 dB in relatively quiet zones and 50 dB in noisy and public zones, so the authors' 45 dB quiet-area value corresponds to the code's middle category.
  • Temperature: maximum air temperatures were 37.5 °C, 35.5 °C and 32.3 °C in the three zones of the personal and public module, between 30.5 and 31.4 °C in the four zones of the open module, and the cooperative module ranged from 27.9 to 30.7 °C. Against the 25 to 27 °C summer range in JGJ 38-2015, the authors conclude that none of the three spaces met the requirement. In the code text consulted, that range is a recommended design parameter for air-conditioned library rooms, not an operational limit for every hour of use.
  • Air quality: carbon dioxide (CO2) reached maximum values of 1,048 ppm and 830 ppm in two zones of the personal and public module and 887 ppm in the cooperative module. The authors state that indoor CO2 should not exceed 1,000 ppm and that a library, as a densely occupied space, should be kept within 800 ppm, attributing both values to the Chinese standard GB 50325-2020, whose text could not be consulted for this article. The researchers assessed CO2 concentrations against the reference level applied in their study. Such thresholds depend on the applicable standard, occupancy assumptions and measurement context, and should not be treated as universal indoor-air quality limits. CO2 mainly indicates how well an occupied room is ventilated; it is not a complete measure of indoor air safety. In two of the three modules, formaldehyde exceeded 100 µg/m³ between 3:00 and 4:00 p.m., a limit the authors also attribute to GB 50325-2020.

Guangzhou: a different library, a different problem

A second study from an overlapping research team, published in Buildings on 15 December 2025, measured a learning cluster on the third floor of the Guangdong University of Technology library from 9:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. over two weeks, from 8 to 22 October 2023, and obtained 742 valid questionnaires. Here the dominant problems were different. The highest average illuminance in any area was 222.94 lux. The authors report that average illuminance fell short of the 300 lux value they cite from China's building lighting standard for most of the day, and that after 5:30 p.m. the cluster as a whole was below 150 lux. Carbon dioxide peaked at 486 ppm, within the 800 ppm level the authors apply, which they again attribute to GB 50325-2020. Average noise was 52.40 and 50.20 dB in the two areas the authors classed as quiet zones, above the 45 dB they apply to quiet zones, and 53.20 and 56.60 dB in the two areas classed as dynamic zones, above the 50 dB they apply there. Midday temperatures, peaking at 28.4 °C, exceeded the 25 to 27 °C summer range.

The contrast matters for evaluation. Two libraries in the same city, measured weeks apart in the same year, had different dominant failures: heat, glare and loud noise peaks in one; dim evening lighting and average noise above the applied limits in the other. A single institution-wide score would hide this.

Hong Kong: optimal ranges for concentration

Zhang, Hamida, Mui and Wong (Buildings, published 5 February 2026) logged air temperature, radiant temperature, air velocity, relative humidity and sound pressure level at one-minute intervals, from 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m., in four study areas (self-study and group-study areas on two floors) of The Hong Kong Polytechnic University library on ten weekdays between 19 October and 1 November 2022, alongside 381 valid questionnaires on concentration, perceptions and satisfaction. From these readings they calculated operative temperature and the background noise indicator LA90, the A-weighted level exceeded for 90% of the measurement period. They found significant interactive effects between operative temperature, humidity and background noise. Using multi-objective optimization of their models of satisfaction and concentration, they proposed ranges of 22.6 to 24.8 °C operative temperature, 41.0 to 48.4% relative humidity and 45.0 to 48.5 dB(A) LA90, and reported that existing conditions exceeded these levels, particularly on the first floor. These ranges are model-derived optima for one air-conditioned library and one student population, not regulatory standards, so they are best read as an example of how thermal and acoustic factors interact, not as universal targets.

Kuala Lumpur: a tropical campus library with data loggers

Aflaki, Esfandiari and Jarrahi (Buildings, published 8 May 2023) assessed the Zaba Memorial Library on the University of Malaya campus in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, covering Nadir's room, which houses rare and special collections, and the main library hall. Eight HOBO data loggers and sensors recorded air temperature, relative humidity and air velocity, while noise and air quality were measured with separate instruments. Average carbon dioxide in the hall was 479.5 ppm, reaching 588 ppm, as recorded by one of the two air-quality instruments listed. But light intensity in the reading area was below 300 lux, and mean air velocity at seated head height was 0.05 m/s, below the 0.15 to 0.50 m/s range that the authors attribute to MS 1525, Malaysia's code of practice on energy efficiency in non-residential buildings (they cite its 2014 edition; a third revision was declared in 2019). Noise in the hall ranged from 43 to 61 dB(A) depending on the number of users and their activities; against an acceptable range of 38 to 48 dB(A) cited by the authors, four zones were within range and the entrance and Nadir's room were noisy. The reading zone was found to be thermally uncomfortable, and Nadir's room was judged unsuitable for rare collections because its average temperature exceeded the preservation threshold the authors applied. Because the study assessed both a collection room and a reading hall, it is also a reminder that a library has to serve readers and collections, whose needs are not identical.

Do Better Library Conditions Improve Learning?

The measurement studies above describe conditions, not outcomes. The evidence linking library conditions to learning is thinner and mostly survey-based.

Xie and Zakaria (International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education, 2026) surveyed 383 students at Fuzhou University in Fujian Province, China, in March 2025. Library IEQ was measured through students' questionnaire ratings, not instruments, and academic achievement through cumulative grade point average. In this single survey, perceived library IEQ positively predicted both learning engagement and academic achievement, with engagement acting as a partial mediating mechanism. The authors note that "little empirical evidence exists regarding its academic influence in university libraries," and they list the single-institution sample and the reliance on grade point average as limitations. The finding is an association in one university's student sample, and it cannot show that improving a reading hall raises grades.

Zheng and colleagues (Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, March 2024) analyzed a final sample of 1,060 students from a survey of Chinese universities conducted between October 2021 and January 2022. In a structural model controlling for year of study, major, monthly spending and gender, the library environment, as students reported it, was positively associated with learning engagement (standardized total effect 0.320), and part of this association ran through interaction among students (indirect effect 0.072). The pattern differed between liberal arts and science students: for liberal arts students the association was direct, with no significant mediation through interaction, while for science students it was partly mediated by interaction. Again, the measures were perceptions, not instrument readings, and the cross-sectional design does not establish cause and effect.

Our Interpretation

Taken together, this evidence supports a cautious reading: library environment is plausibly connected to engagement, and engagement to achievement, but the studies are correlational, regional and perception-based. That does not justify treating a library as better because it is two degrees cooler. It does support treating physical conditions as a legitimate aspect of facility quality, because they are measurable, they differ widely between spaces in the same building, and they are largely within institutional control.

The studies also show why measurement and opinion should be kept apart. In the Guangzhou studies, students' stated priorities centered on illuminance, noise, privacy and temperature, but the measured failures differed by building. A student survey of library satisfaction concerns student experience, which the Student Experience & Satisfaction dimension addresses. A sensor-based record of temperature, light, noise and carbon dioxide in the same rooms describes what the university provides. A satisfied cohort does not prove that conditions meet any standard, and a comfortable library cannot be demonstrated by quoting satisfaction scores. Keeping the two separate avoids circular evaluation.

Finally, seat counts and conditions answer different questions. In the Guangzhou case, the same study modules that offered seating recorded air temperatures up to 37.5 °C and maximum noise levels up to 85 dB. Capacity statistics alone can therefore overstate provision.

How Could Library Indoor Conditions Be Measured Responsibly?

The studies suggest a workable core set of measures, summarized below as a proposal for institutions and evaluators, not as UNIRANKS indicators. Thresholds should come from a named standard, applied consistently, with its edition, its status (mandatory requirement, design value or guidance) and the local climate noted. No single reading, and no single room, can establish whether a whole library meets a standard.

Core measures of library study-space conditions, how they can be measured, and reference points in the reviewed studies
Parameter What is measured How it can be measured Standard or reference in the reviewed studies Measurement limitations Scope of institutional reporting
Thermal comfort Air temperature, relative humidity, air velocity; operative temperature where radiant temperature is also logged Calibrated loggers at seated head height (about 1.1 m) in each zone, logging at short intervals through opening hours Design parameters in national codes (JGJ 38-2015 in China; MS 1525 as cited in Malaysia); model-derived ranges such as the Hong Kong study, which are not regulatory Short campaigns miss afternoon, summer and examination-period peaks; one logger may not represent a whole floor Share of seats or zones within the stated range, by season and time of day
Air quality Carbon dioxide as a ventilation indicator; formaldehyde and particles where relevant; signs of dampness and mould Calibrated CO2 sensors in occupied zones, with occupancy recorded; periodic pollutant sampling; building inspection for dampness Values the Chinese studies attribute to GB 50325-2020 (800 or 1,000 ppm CO2); WHO guidelines on dampness and mould (2009), which set no numerical threshold and recommend preventing persistent dampness CO2 reflects ventilation relative to occupancy, not overall air safety; readings depend on how full the room is; thresholds differ by standard Peak and typical CO2 by zone with occupancy stated, and the reference level used
Lighting Illuminance at desk height across the day, with and without artificial light; glare Calibrated light meters or loggers at desk height on a grid of seats, repeated at fixed hours Reading-room values in the Chinese standards cited (100 lux minimum in GB 9669-1996, now abolished; 300 lux design value for reading rooms) Daily averages hide glare at noon and shortfalls in the evening; results vary seat by seat Share of seats meeting the stated value at defined hours, including evenings
Acoustics Background noise and noise events by zone type (quiet, group, social) Sound level meters reporting time-averaged levels (LAeq over a stated period) and statistical indicators (LA90 for background noise), kept separate from maximum levels Zone-specific design limits in JGJ 38-2015 (40, 45 and 50 dB(A) by zone category, applied by the studies as 45 dB quiet and 50 dB dynamic); Hong Kong study range, which is model-derived Comparing an instantaneous peak with a limit for average levels overstates exceedance; one average for a mixed-use floor hides quiet and noisy zones Time-averaged and background levels by zone type, with the averaging period and the limit used
Coverage and reporting Which seats, zones, hours and weeks the measurements represent A sampling plan covering representative zones, opening hours and seasons, with instrument calibration and occupancy recorded Zone and time-series protocols in the Guangzhou studies Single-week or single-room campaigns cannot show year-round conditions; measurement uncertainty is rarely reported Results for all measured zones, not only the best-performing room, with sampling, calibration and uncertainty stated

A comparable approach would also specify sampling: which seats, which hours, which weeks (including examination periods and the hottest and coldest weeks), and which instruments, with their calibration. Readings should be time-averaged over stated periods, linked to recorded occupancy, and reported with their uncertainty, so that a single high or low value is not mistaken for the typical condition of a room. The Guangzhou design, with sensors across defined zones for twelve hours a day, is a practical model. Institutions that already run building management systems may hold some of this data without publishing it.

Practical Steps for University Leaders and Evaluators

  • Measure before renovating. A short logger campaign across seasons can show whether the main problem is noise, heat, light or ventilation, which differ by building.
  • Publish zone-level results. Reporting the share of seats within a named standard is more informative than a general claim of modern facilities.
  • Measure with and without artificial lighting. Both Guangzhou studies found that daylight and evening conditions can fail in opposite directions.
  • Separate measurement from opinion. Collect sensor data and student feedback independently, then compare them.
  • State the standard and the climate. A reading is meaningful only against a named threshold, and comfort thresholds should reflect local conditions and cooling practices.
  • Do not oversell outcomes. Current evidence supports plausible links to engagement, not guaranteed gains in grades.

Limitations

Several limits need to be stated plainly before any measure is built on this evidence.

  • Few buildings. The most detailed study measured one library out of ten surveyed; the others cover one learning cluster, four study areas or one library hall and a collection room. There is no multi-country, multi-institution dataset of measured library conditions in these studies.
  • Short and seasonal windows. The measurement periods were one week (September 2023), two weeks (October 2023) and ten weekdays (October and November 2022); the Kuala Lumpur paper does not state its measurement period clearly. Conditions in examination periods, winter or other seasons are not covered.
  • Different thresholds. The studies compare readings against different references: Chinese design and pollution-control codes, a Malaysian energy-efficiency code of practice, and values taken from the literature. Some of these are design parameters rather than operational limits, and one (GB 9669-1996) is now listed as abolished. The two Guangzhou papers also apply the same carbon dioxide reference differently: one notes a general 1,000 ppm level but applies 800 ppm to densely occupied libraries, the other cites 800 ppm directly. Results are comparable only when the threshold, its source and the averaging period are stated.
  • Peaks and averages. Some comparisons in the studies set maximum recorded noise levels against limits for average levels, which shows that loud events occur but overstates how far typical conditions exceed the limit.
  • Geographic concentration. The measured evidence comes from southern China, Hong Kong and Malaysia. Climate, building stock, cooling practices and norms about noise vary widely, so thresholds do not transfer automatically to Africa, the Middle East, Latin America or Europe.
  • Weak outcome evidence. The learning links rest on surveys of Chinese students' perceptions; one study uses grade point average as its outcome, and neither can establish cause and effect.
  • Materials consulted. All six research papers were read in full in their publishers' open-access versions. Access to the technical standards was limited: JGJ 38-2015 was consulted in a copy published by a Guangzhou district government, EN 16798-1, GB 9669-1996 and MS 1525 through official catalogue or declaration records, and the WHO guidelines in full. The text of GB 50325-2020 was not available, so the values attributed to it, and the MS 1525 air-velocity range, are reported as the papers state them.

Conclusion

The physical conditions of a university library are measurable, vary substantially within and between buildings, and are largely within institutional control. The field studies reviewed here are few and concentrated in East and Southeast Asia, so they support a method rather than a global benchmark. They show that capacity figures can conceal real shortfalls, that different libraries fail in different ways, and that the evidence linking conditions to achievement remains associational. A careful assessment would therefore combine seat and service data with zone-level, seasonal, standard-referenced measurements of noise, light, heat and air quality, reported separately from student opinion.

Related Reading on UNIRANKS

For the wider evidence on facilities and outcomes, see How Do Campus Facilities Influence Student Success? and What Should Universities Measure When Evaluating Student Wellbeing & Facilities?. More articles are collected in Student Wellbeing & Facilities research.

Editorial disclosure

UNIRANKS publishes university rankings, and its methodology includes a Student Wellbeing & Facilities dimension. This article reviews independent research on measured indoor conditions in university libraries and study spaces. It does not describe how UNIRANKS scores institutions.

Research References

  1. Wang, L., Guo, W., Liu, X., et al. (2026). Strategies for designing informal learning spaces in libraries based on comprehensive field measurements of light, noise, thermal, and air quality. Scientific Reports, 16(1), 17101. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-47011-w (verified 21 November 2026)
  2. Wang, L., Song, J., Guo, W., et al. (2025). Impact of Multiple Environmental Factors of Space Clusters for Informal Learning in Library Renovation and Update. Buildings, 15(24), 4530. https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings15244530 (verified 21 November 2026)
  3. Zhang, D., Hamida, A., Mui, K.-W., et al. (2026). Spatiotemporal Interactive Effects Between Thermal Comfort and Acoustic Quality on University Students' Performance and Satisfaction in Hong Kong. Buildings, 16(3), 670. https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings16030670 (verified 21 November 2026)
  4. Aflaki, A., Esfandiari, M., Jarrahi, A. (2023). Multi-Criteria Evaluation of a Library's Indoor Environmental Quality in the Tropics. Buildings, 13(5), 1233. https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings13051233 (verified 21 November 2026)
  5. Xie, L., Zakaria, S. A. (2026). University library indoor environment quality and student achievement: mediating role of learning engagement. International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE), 15(2), 1598-1606. https://doi.org/10.11591/ijere.v15i2.35471 (verified 21 November 2026)
  6. Zheng, Z., Zeng, M., Huang, W., et al. (2024). The influence of university library environment on student interactions and college students' learning engagement. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11(1), 385. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-024-02892-y (verified 21 November 2026)

Sources

Share this article